Affiliate disclosure: This Charter Arms Bulldog review contains affiliate links. If you buy through our links then we can receive a small commission that helps keep the lights on. You don’t pay anything more.
- Treat every gun as loaded
- Point the muzzle in a safe direction
- Keep your finger off the trigger until you’re ready to shoot
- Know your target and what’s beyond
Table of Contents
How we tested: Every pick here is ranked against our testing methodology. Minimum round counts, accuracy and reliability protocols, the failures that disqualify a gun. Where we have not shot a specific variant ourselves, we say so in that section.
Review: Charter Arms Bulldog – The Only .44 Special Left
Our Rating: 7.3/10
Here is a thing worth knowing before you read another word. We pulled every in-stock .44 Special firearm across the retailers we track, and 51 of them are Charter Arms. Everything else on that list is a lever action rifle, a cowboy single action, or a Smith and Wesson costing four figures. If you want a double action .44 Special revolver you can carry, in 2026, this is basically the only one being made. That changes how you review it.
Specifications: Bulldog, stainless (SKU 74420)
- MSRP: $471.23
- Street Price: $349.99 (Use our live pricing for the best up to date deal)
- Caliber: .44 Special
- Capacity: 5 rounds
- Action: Double action / single action, or double action only on the Pug
- Barrel: 2.5 inches standard, 3 inches on the Classic, 4.2 inches on the Target
- Weight: 19 to 22 oz depending on model
- Frame: Large, 416 stainless steel
- Finish: Traditional polish, Blacknitride or blued depending on SKU
- Sights: Fixed, adjustable on the Target Bulldog
- Grip: Combat full rubber, walnut on the Classic, Crimson Trace laser on 74424
- Trigger Guard: Polymer
- Models in the series: 9
Pros
- Nothing else offers .44 Special
- Twenty ounces for five big rounds
- Under half a Ruger SP101
Cons
- Recoil is genuinely unpleasant
- Ammunition is scarce and expensive
- Fixed sights on most models
Quick Take
The Bulldog is a large frame five shot revolver that weighs about the same as a steel .38 snub and fires a cartridge with roughly twice the bullet weight. That combination is the whole appeal and the whole problem. Twenty ounces of stainless steel and a 246 grain bullet is not a comfortable pairing, and anybody who tells you otherwise has shot half a cylinder and put it down.
What it does give you is a genuinely large caliber in a package you can put in a coat pocket, at a street price of around $350. There is no competition for that, because the industry quietly stopped building affordable .44 Special double actions and never restarted. The Bulldog survived because Charter never stopped making it.
Best For: Anybody who specifically wants .44 Special in a carry sized revolver, woods carry against two legged and four legged problems at short range, and shooters who prefer one big slow bullet to five fast small ones. A poor choice as a first revolver or as a gun you plan to shoot often.
Why Nobody Else Builds This Gun
We ran the numbers rather than guessing at them. Across every in-stock .44 Special listing in the retailers we track, the breakdown by maker looks like this:
| Maker | In-stock listings | What they are | Cheapest |
| Charter Arms | 51 | Carry revolvers | $310 |
| Henry | 35 | Lever action rifles | $537 |
| Cimarron | 8 | Single action revolvers | $555 |
| Marlin | 6 | Lever action rifles | $1,036 |
| Smith & Wesson | 5 | Premium revolvers | $999 |
| Colt | 4 | Single action revolvers | $1,450 |
Read that table properly and the conclusion is unavoidable. Outside Charter Arms there is no double action .44 Special revolver under a thousand dollars currently in the channel. The cartridge survives mostly as a lever gun round and a cowboy round. Charter is the only company still making the thing the .44 Special was invented for, which is a defensive revolver you can actually carry.
That matters when you judge the gun. The Bulldog is not the best revolver at this price, and if you cross shop it against a .357 you will find better made guns. It is the only one that does this specific thing, and there is no premium version to trade up to.
The Nine Bulldogs, and the One Made of Different Steel
Charter’s own catalog lists nine models in the Bulldog series. Almost all are 416 stainless, 2.5 inch, five shot .44 Specials that differ only in finish and grip. Two are genuinely different guns.
Bulldog standard, 2.5 inch, 20 oz $350-$472 MSRP
Bulldog Pug, bobbed hammer $360-$410
Classic Bulldog, carbon steel, walnut $505 MSRP
Target Bulldog, 4.2 inch, adjustable $383-$469
Bulldog Boomer, ported 2 inch $365-$439
Bulldog with Crimson Trace laser $630 MSRP
Bulldog in .45, X-Large frame $501 MSRP
The Classic Bulldog, SKU 34431, is the interesting one. It is the only carbon steel firearm in Charter’s entire 125 model catalog, finished in black oxide, with a 3 inch barrel and classic walnut grips carrying a medallion. Everything else Charter builds is 416 stainless or 7075 aluminum. If you want a Bulldog that looks like a revolver from 1975 rather than a modern working gun, that is the SKU, and it lists at $505.18.
The other outlier is the Target Bulldog, which stretches the barrel to 4.2 inches, adds adjustable sights and puts weight up to 22 ounces. Every complaint in this review about recoil and sights is quieter on that gun, and it costs about $85 more on the street. If you plan to shoot the thing rather than carry it, buy that one.
Range Testing: 300 Rounds of .44 Special
Our test gun was a stainless Bulldog Pug, the 2.5 inch bobbed hammer version, shot across four sessions between November and February at 7, 10 and 15 yards. Temperatures ran from 26 to 51 degrees. Three hundred rounds total, and I will be honest that getting to 300 took longer than it should have.
Recoil, Which Is the Whole Story
Twenty ounces firing a 246 grain lead round nose at around 750 feet per second produces recoil that is slow and heavy rather than sharp. It is not the whip crack of a light .357, it is a shove, and the gun rolls in the hand every single shot. Twenty five rounds was a comfortable session. Fifty was a decision. The combat rubber grip covers the backstrap and does real work, and I would not want to shoot this gun with the walnut grips fitted to the Classic.
The practical consequence is that split times between shots are slow, and getting back on target for a second round takes real effort. Anybody buying this as a defensive gun needs to accept that five rounds is what they have, because the sixth and seventh shots off a fresh reload are going somewhere approximate.
Reliability
No failures to fire across all 300 rounds. Ejection was clean with standard pressure loads. The Buffalo Bore Anti-Personnel 200 grain wadcutters, which run considerably hotter, left cases that needed a firm smack on the ejector rod rather than a push. That is normal on a short ejector rod with a stout load and it is worth knowing before it happens under pressure.
Accuracy
Off a rest at 15 yards, five shot groups with Winchester 246 grain lead round nose averaged 3.5 inches, with the best at 2.9. That is better than a fixed sight 2.5 inch barrel has any right to be, and the big slow bullet is part of why. Speer Gold Dot 200 grain shot around 3.8 inches and hit closer to point of aim. Point of impact with the 246 grain load ran about three inches high at 15 yards, which is a common trait on fixed sight revolvers regulated for heavier bullets.
The Ammunition Problem
This needs saying plainly because it affects whether you should buy the gun. .44 Special is not a cheap or common cartridge. Range fodder costs roughly two to three times what .38 Special costs per round, and no shop stocks it deeply. Defensive loads exist and are good, but the selection is a handful of options rather than a wall. Budget for buying ammunition when you find it rather than when you want it, and plan on shooting this gun far less than you would shoot a .38.
Ammunition Log
- Winchester Super-X 246 gr LRN: 160 rounds
- Remington 246 gr LRN: 80 rounds
- Speer Gold Dot 200 gr JHP: 40 rounds
- Buffalo Bore 200 gr Anti-Personnel wadcutter: 20 rounds
What This Means for You
- Recoil: Buy it knowing you will shoot it less than you should. Twenty five rounds is a session, not a warm up.
- Ammunition: Buy .44 Special when you see it. Do not assume you can pick some up on the way to the range.
- Ejection: Hit the rod once, hard, with the barrel vertical. Hot loads will stick if you ease it.
- Zero: Ours shot high with 246 grain. Check yours with the load you will actually carry, not the cheap stuff.
- Grips: Keep the rubber. The walnut on the Classic looks better and will hurt considerably more.
Technical Deep Dive
The Large Frame
Charter builds the Bulldog on what it calls the Large frame, against the Small frame that carries the .38 Special Undercover. The .45 version moves up again to an X-Large frame. That matters for two practical reasons. Holsters cut for a Charter Undercover will not fit a Bulldog, and the extra frame is why the gun weighs twenty ounces rather than seventeen while holding the same five rounds.
Why .44 Special Works in a Short Barrel
A .44 Special is a large, heavy, slow bullet loaded to modest pressure, and that is exactly the profile that suffers least from a short barrel. A .357 Magnum out of two and a half inches loses a great deal of the velocity its terminal performance depends on, and returns the loss as muzzle flash and noise. The .44 Special was never going fast in the first place, so it arrives at the target doing roughly what the box says. That is the honest engineering case for this gun and it is a good one.
Finish Options
Charter offers the Bulldog in traditional polish stainless, a Blacknitride treatment on the 6 prefix SKUs, matte black or blued on the 1 prefix guns, and black oxide over carbon steel on the Classic. Blacknitride is the most corrosion resistant of them and costs about fourteen dollars more at list. For a gun that will live in a pocket against a sweaty body, that is money well spent.
| Component | Specification | Why it matters |
| Frame | Large, 416 stainless | Undercover holsters will not fit |
| Barrel | 2.5 inches, 3 or 4.2 on variants | The 4.2 is the shootable one |
| Weight | 19 to 22 oz | Light for the cartridge, and you feel it |
| Capacity | 5 rounds | Standard for the class, no six shot option |
| Trigger guard | Polymer on every model | Part of how the price stays low |
| Classic Bulldog | Carbon steel, black oxide | The only carbon steel gun Charter builds |
How It Compares
Taurus 605 ($309-$350)
The obvious cross shop, and the one most buyers should think about hardest. The 605 is a five shot .357 Magnum snub for roughly the same money, and .357 and .38 Special ammunition is everywhere and cheap. That last point is not a small thing: you will shoot the Taurus three times as much because you can afford to. What the Taurus cannot do is give you a .44 caliber bullet, and a .357 out of a two inch barrel gives back a lot of what makes it a .357.
Ruger SP101 ($580-$730)
The best made revolver in this comparison by a wide margin, and roughly double the Bulldog’s street price. The SP101 is built like a bank vault, weighs about 26 ounces in .357, and will outlast everything here. It is also heavier, holds the same five rounds, and does not chamber .44 Special. Buy the Ruger if what you want is a small revolver that will never wear out. Buy the Charter if what you want is specifically this cartridge.
Charter Arms Undercover ($235-$350)
Charter’s own .38 Special, on the smaller frame, at roughly $100 less. It is lighter, far cheaper to feed, and much easier to shoot well. For most buyers looking at a Charter revolver it is the more sensible gun, and the Bulldog only wins if the .44 caliber is the actual requirement rather than a preference. Our Charter Arms Undercover review goes through that gun in detail, including the naming trap that catches people out.
Verdict: the Taurus is the better buy for most people, the Ruger is the better gun, and the Charter is the only one that fires the cartridge you came here for. For the wider field see our best .44 Magnum revolvers and best .38 Special revolvers guides.
Upgrades Worth Making
| Upgrade | Recommended | Why it matters | Cost |
| Grip | Pachmayr or Hogue for a Charter large frame | The single change that most reduces the pain | $30 – $60 |
| Front sight paint | Bright orange or white | The fixed front sight is hard to pick up quickly | $8 – $15 |
| Speed strips | Any .44 caliber speed strip | Speed loaders for this frame are hard to find | $10 – $20 |
| Holster | Leather cut for a Charter large frame | An Undercover holster will not fit this gun | $40 – $90 |
Common Problems and Fixes
- Cases sticking after hot loads: the ejector rod is short on a 2.5 inch gun. Barrel vertical, one firm strike on the rod. Easing it is what causes the problem.
- Shooting high at close range: ours printed about three inches high at 15 yards with 246 grain. Fixed sight revolvers are regulated for a particular bullet weight. Find the load that hits where you look.
- Cannot find ammunition: this is the real ownership problem, not a fault. Buy .44 Special whenever you see it in stock, because nobody carries it deep.
- Holster does not fit: the Bulldog is a Large frame and the .45 version is X-Large. Neither shares a holster with the small frame Undercover.
- Recoil is worse than expected: that is the gun, not a defect. Fit a bigger rubber grip and shoot 200 grain loads rather than 246 grain.
Who Should NOT Buy This Gun
- The first time revolver buyer: starting on a 20 ounce .44 teaches you a flinch and nothing else. Buy a Charter Undercover or a Taurus 856 in .38 Special and learn on that.
- Anyone who wants to practice regularly: .44 Special costs two to three times what .38 does and no shop stocks it deeply. A Taurus 605 in .357 will get shot three times as often.
- The recoil sensitive shooter: this is the hardest kicking gun of its size in the comparison. A Ruger SP101 in .38 Special weighs more and hurts far less.
- Anyone wanting a range revolver: fixed sights and a 2.5 inch barrel are a defensive package. Buy the Target Bulldog with its 4.2 inch barrel and adjustable sights instead.
- The buyer chasing magnum power: .44 Special is not .44 Magnum and does not pretend to be. If you want magnum performance, a Smith and Wesson 69 or a Ruger GP100 is the honest answer.
Final Verdict
The Bulldog is not a refined revolver and it never was. The finish is plain, the sights are a groove and a ramp, the trigger guard is polymer, and twenty ounces of gun firing a 246 grain bullet is an experience rather than a pleasure. Three hundred rounds produced no failures to fire, which is the bar that matters, and around three and a half inches at 15 yards, which is more than enough for what it is for.
What earns it the score is that nothing else exists. Fifty one of the .44 Special guns in stock across the retailers we track wear a Charter Arms rollmark, and outside that there is no double action .44 Special carry revolver under a thousand dollars. If that cartridge in that size is the requirement, this is the gun, and at $350 it is not asking much. If it is merely a preference, buy the Taurus, shoot it three times as often, and be better with it.
Model specifications, SKUs, weights, frame sizes and MSRP figures come from the Charter Arms product catalog, covering all 125 current models. Prices are the live in-stock range across the retailers we track and will move.
Final Score: 7.3/10 – Plain, punishing and the only one of its kind, which turns out to be a strong enough argument.
FAQ: Charter Arms Bulldog
Is the Charter Arms Bulldog a good revolver?
For its one job, yes. Ours fired 300 rounds of .44 Special with no failures to fire and grouped around 3.5 inches at 15 yards from a 2.5 inch barrel. It is plain, the sights are fixed and the recoil is heavy, but it is the only affordable double action .44 Special carry revolver still being made, so there is nothing better to compare it against.
How much does a Charter Arms Bulldog cost?
Charter lists the stainless model at $471.23, with the range running to $630.11 for the Crimson Trace laser version. On the street the in-stock band is about $350 to $610, and the cheapest we found at a major retailer was $349.99. The Target Bulldog with its longer barrel runs roughly $85 more.
Does anyone else make a .44 Special revolver?
Barely. Across every in-stock .44 Special listing at the retailers we track, 51 are Charter Arms. The rest are Henry and Marlin lever rifles, Cimarron and Colt single actions, and a handful of Smith and Wessons starting near $1,000. There is no other double action .44 Special carry revolver under a thousand dollars currently in the channel.
How bad is the recoil on a Charter Arms Bulldog?
Heavy, but slow rather than sharp. A 20 ounce revolver firing a 246 grain bullet shoves rather than cracks, and the gun rolls in the hand on every shot. Twenty five rounds is a comfortable session. Keep the rubber combat grip, because the walnut grips on the Classic Bulldog will make it considerably worse.
What is the difference between the Bulldog and the Bulldog Pug?
The Pug is the bobbed hammer, double action only version of the same 2.5 inch gun, which means it will not snag coming out of a pocket. The standard Bulldog has an exposed hammer and gives you a single action pull. Same frame, same cartridge, same five rounds, and within about $20 of each other.
What is the Classic Bulldog?
SKU 34431, and it is the only carbon steel firearm in Charter's entire 125 model catalog. Everything else Charter builds is 416 stainless or 7075 aluminum. It has a black oxide finish, a 3 inch barrel and walnut grips with a medallion, and lists at $505.18. Buy it for the look, and expect more recoil from the harder grips.
Will a Charter Undercover holster fit a Bulldog?
No. Charter builds the Undercover on its Small frame and the Bulldog on the Large frame, with the .45 version moving up again to X-Large. Buy a holster cut for a Charter large frame specifically. This catches a lot of people who assume the two guns share a shape because they share a maker.
Charter Arms Bulldog or Taurus 605?
The Taurus is the better buy for most people. It is a five shot .357 Magnum at roughly the same money, and .357 and .38 Special ammunition is cheap and everywhere, so you will practice three times as much. The Bulldog wins only if the .44 caliber bullet is an actual requirement, and there is a real argument that a big slow bullet suits a short barrel better than a magnum does.
6,106+ Gun & Ammo Deals
Updated daily from 200+ top retailers. Filter by category, caliber, action type, and price.
Related Guides