8 Best Shotguns for Deer Hunting in 2026: Slug Guns, Pumps, and Semi-Autos

Last updated March 29th 2026

Some of the links below are affiliate links, meaning at no additional cost to you, we may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.

Best Shotguns for Deer Hunting in 2026 at a Glance

The Best Shotguns for Deer Hunting in 2026

If you hunt deer in Michigan, Ohio, Indiana, or any other slug-only state, you already know the deal: no rifles allowed, period. Your shotgun isn’t just a backup option. It’s the only legal tool for the job. And yet I still see hunters showing up to the woods with whatever pump they happened to own, shooting Foster slugs out of a bird barrel, wondering why their accuracy falls apart past 75 yards.

Deer hunting with a shotgun has changed a lot over the last two decades. Rifled barrels, saboted slugs, and optic-ready receivers have pushed effective range out to 150 yards or more with the right setup. A good slug gun isn’t just compensating for a rifle ban. At close range in thick brush, it’s arguably a better tool than a rifle anyway.

I’ve hunted with a mix of pumps, bolt guns, and semi-autos over the years, and I’ve spent time specifically chasing whitetail in restricted zones where slugs are the law. The guns on this list are ones I’ve either shot extensively, hunted behind, or handled enough to give you a real opinion. Check out our best slug gun guide and best hunting shotguns roundup for more context on how these fit the broader landscape.

Quick note before we dive in: if your state allows rifles, you’ll almost always be better served by a deer rifle. This guide is specifically for slug-only zones, restricted zones, and hunters who want a dedicated slug gun for close-range work. For ammo recommendations to pair with these guns, see our best 12-gauge slugs guide.

---

1. Savage 220. Best Overall Deer Shotgun

• Gauge: 20 gauge
• Barrel: 22″ fully rifled
• Action: Bolt-action
• Weight: 7.5 lbs.
• Capacity: 2+1
• MSRP: ~$699

The Savage 220 is what happens when you stop pretending a shotgun is a shotgun and start treating it like a precision deer rifle. Bolt-action, fully rifled 22-inch barrel, and that legendary Accutrigger. I put a compact 2-7x scope on mine and it shoots groups I’d be happy with out of a dedicated deer rifle. We’re talking 2-inch groups at 100 yards with Hornady SST Lite sabots.

20-gauge platform surprises a lot of people. It’s lighter, it kicks less, and honestly the ballistics difference between a 20-gauge sabot and a 12-gauge sabot at 100 yards is pretty marginal for whitetail hunting. I’ve sat in treestands with this gun for full-day hunts and never once felt under-gunned.

One knock is the bolt-action. If a deer steps out and you take a shot, a fast follow-up is not this gun’s strength. For most deer hunting situations that’s fine. But if you hunt areas where you regularly see multiple deer at once, the pump or semi-auto options lower on this list will serve you better.

Best For: Slug-only state hunters who want maximum accuracy and rifle-like performance from a shotgun platform. If you’re shooting across 100-yard fields in Michigan or Indiana, nothing on this list touches it.

---

2. Mossberg 500 Slugster. Best Value Pump for Deer

• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Barrel: 24″ ported, rifled
• Action: Pump-action
• Weight: 7.0 lbs.
• Capacity: 5+1
• MSRP: ~$459

Mossberg 500 Slugster might be the best value proposition in deer hunting. Under $460 for a pump with a factory-rifled barrel and a receiver drilled for a scope. I’ve seen hunters run these guns season after season in the thick hardwood ridges of Ohio and never have a complaint worth mentioning.

It shoots. Reliably, consistently, without drama. The porting helps keep the muzzle in check with hot 3-inch loads, which matters when you’re trying to keep your shot picture together for a quick follow-up.

Accuracy is genuinely solid for the price. Running Federal Trophy Copper or Hornady SST sabots, I’ve put consistent 3-inch groups at 100 yards from a bench. The trigger is heavy with some creep, but most hunters just learn to shoot around it.

Best For: First-time slug gun buyers, hunters on a tight budget, or anyone who needs a reliable pump for close-to-medium-range whitetail work in a slug-only zone.

---

3. Remington 870 SPS Slug. Best Classic Pump

• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Barrel: 23″ fully rifled
• Action: Pump-action
• Weight: 7.25 lbs.
• Capacity: 4+1
• MSRP: ~$529

The Remington 870 has probably killed more whitetail deer in the United States than any other shotgun platform. The action is smooth, the handling is familiar, and anyone who’s spent time with shotguns has almost certainly cycled an 870 before. There’s something to be said for picking up a gun and already knowing how it runs.

SPS Slug variant comes with a fully rifled 23-inch barrel and a synthetic stock that laughs at wet weather and cold mornings. Mount a compact scope or a red dot and you’re ready to hunt deer at distances that seemed unrealistic with a slug gun 20 years ago.

Post-bankruptcy Remington situation deserves mention. Quality control under RemArms ownership has improved compared to the Freedom Group era, but it is still early days. Recent production 870s and 700s are showing better fit and finish. Check recent buyer reviews and inspect the action for smooth cycling and the finish quality before you commit. See our shotgun buying guide for more context.

Best For: Hunters who want a proven, familiar pump-action platform with massive aftermarket support. Great for thick cover shots where fast cycling matters more than precision at distance.

---

4. Ithaca Deerslayer III. Best Premium Pump

• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Barrel: 24″ fully rifled, bottom-ejecting
• Action: Pump-action (bottom-ejecting)
• Weight: 7.0 lbs.
• Capacity: 4+1
• MSRP: ~$1,149

Most people have never handled an Ithaca Deerslayer III. That’s a shame, because this gun is a genuine standout. The bottom-ejecting action works equally well for left- and right-handed shooters, and nothing is flying past your face when you work the action quickly.

Pump stroke on this gun is something you need to feel to appreciate. Ithaca makes these in Ohio with actual attention to fit and finish, and you can feel the difference the moment you shoulder it. At over $1,100 it’s a real investment, but you’re getting a slug gun that could genuinely be a family heirloom.

Accuracy with quality sabots is excellent. The fully rifled barrel and a decent scope setup will get you inside 3 inches at 100 yards consistently. For treestand hunting over food plots in New York or Pennsylvania, this is a premium option that punches well above typical pump-gun expectations.

Best For: The serious slug-state hunter who wants the best pump-action money can buy. If you want a gun that’ll outlast you and your kids, this is it.

---

5. Benelli SBE3 Rifled Slug. Best Semi-Auto

• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Barrel: 24″ fully rifled slug barrel
• Action: Semi-auto (inertia-driven)
• Weight: 7.1 lbs.
• Capacity: 3+1
• MSRP: ~$1,799

The Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 is the gold standard for semi-auto shotguns, and the factory Rifled Slug version makes it legitimately dangerous in a deer field. Mount a 2-7x scope on it and you have a semi-auto that will shoot with the pumps at 100 yards while giving you a fast second shot if you need it.

That ComforTech stock is the real deal. I’ve shot full boxes of 3-inch slug loads through an SBE3 without wanting to quit. Try that with a basic synthetic-stocked pump and see how your shoulder feels the next morning.

At nearly $1,800, this is a serious investment. But if you hunt birds in the fall and deer in late season with the same gun, the versatility argument gets pretty strong. One gun, two complete setups.

Best For: The hunter who wants maximum versatility from a single premium semi-auto, or anyone hunting situations where a fast follow-up shot on deer is a realistic expectation.

---

6. Winchester SXP Deer. Best Mid-Range Pump

• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Barrel: 22″ fully rifled
• Action: Pump-action
• Weight: 6.75 lbs.
• Capacity: 4+1
• MSRP: ~$479

Winchester’s SXP platform is legitimately fast. The “Speed Pump” marketing is actually grounded in reality. The back-bore design and the action geometry let you cycle this gun quicker than an 870 or a 500. If you’re hunting thick brush where deer jump and run and you might be swinging on a moving target, a fast pump stroke helps.

22-inch rifled barrel makes this one of the more compact options on the list. Under 7 pounds with a shorter barrel is a meaningful advantage when you’re putting on miles still-hunting through hardwoods.

Accuracy is good. Not Savage 220 good, but good enough for confident shots to 100 yards with premium sabot loads. The Inflex recoil pad is better than you’d expect at this price point.

Best For: Hunters who prioritize a lightweight, fast-cycling pump for close-range brush hunting and want a step up from budget options without paying premium prices.

---

7. Browning Maxus II Rifled Deer. Best Semi-Auto Value

• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Barrel: 22″ fully rifled
• Action: Semi-auto, gas-operated
• Weight: 7.25 lbs.
• Capacity: 4+1
• MSRP: ~$1,479

Slug hunter configuration comes with a 22-inch fully rifled barrel and an integral cantilever scope mount right on the barrel itself. That’s a meaningful accuracy advantage over receiver-mounted scopes on semi-autos. When the scope stays with the barrel, your zero holds better through rough handling.

At around 7.25 pounds it carries well for a gas semi-auto. For stationary treestand hunting that weight helps absorb recoil, and the Power Drive gas system soaks up even more of it. Running a 3-inch sabot load from a seated position is genuinely manageable.

At around $1,479, it’s priced between the budget pumps and the Benelli premium tier. If a semi-auto is your priority but you can’t justify the SBE3 price, the Maxus II Rifled Deer is a legitimate alternative.

Best For: Deer hunters who want a dedicated semi-auto slug gun with excellent accuracy and don’t want to spend Benelli money. Particularly strong for treestand hunting where weight is less of a concern.

---

8. Henry Single Shot Slug. Best Budget Deer Shotgun

• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Barrel: 24″ rifled
• Action: Single shot (break-action)
• Weight: 6.0 lbs.
• Capacity: 1
• MSRP: ~$449

People sleep on the Henry Single Shot. Yes, it’s only one round. But think about what most treestand hunting actually looks like. You wait, a deer walks out, you settle in for one good shot. Under those circumstances, a single-shot break-action and a quality rifled barrel is all the gun you need.

Henry makes this gun in America and it shows. The finish quality, the action feel, the overall fit. For under $450, this punches well above its price class. Mount a compact scope and run Federal Trophy Copper Lite sabots through it. The accuracy will surprise you.

At 6 pounds it’s the lightest gun on this list by a margin. If you’re walking miles through hardwood ridges still-hunting, carrying a 7.5-pound bolt gun gets old by mid-morning. This gun doesn’t.

Best For: Youth hunters, budget-conscious hunters, or experienced slug hunters who value lightweight simplicity and are confident in their shot placement. One shot, one deer.

---

Sabot vs. Foster Slugs: What You Need to Know

This question comes up constantly and the answer is straightforward: use sabot slugs in a rifled barrel, and Foster (or Brenneke) slugs in a smoothbore. Running sabots through a smoothbore barrel won’t hurt the gun, but accuracy falls apart fast. The plastic sabot cup is designed to engage rifling. Without it, the slug doesn’t stabilize properly.

Foster slugs in a rifled barrel are the opposite problem. The soft lead slug shoots fine at close range, but it accelerates lead fouling and groups will open up as the barrel gets dirty. If you’re running a rifled barrel, spend the money on quality sabots.

For deer hunting with a rifled barrel, I’d point you toward Hornady SST Lite, Federal Trophy Bonded Tipped, or Remington Premier AccuTip. All three are legitimately accurate at 100 yards. See our full breakdown in the best 12-gauge slugs guide.

---

FAQ: Best Shotgun for Deer Hunting

Frequently Asked Questions