Last updated November 2026 · By Nick Hall, who has followed the AR-15 case from the June 30 cert grant to the final merits brief
Quick take: The gun owners challenging the AR-15 bans in Cook County and Connecticut filed their last brief before the Supreme Court argument on November 20. Their pitch is simple: Heller already decided this, AR-15s are in common use, and the “unusually dangerous” test the bans’ defenders want is balancing under a new name. The justices hear it on Wednesday, December 2.
- What happened: The petitioners in Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins, Nos. 25-238 and 25-566, submitted their merits reply brief on November 20, 2026.
- Why it matters: It is the last brief before argument, and it frames the case as a choice between Heller’s common-use test and a new “unusually dangerous weapons” test.
- What’s next: The consolidated cases get one hour of argument on Wednesday, December 2, 2026, and the United States has leave to argue for the challengers.
- Who to watch: Cook County, whose request to dismiss the Illinois case as moot was still undecided on the docket as of November 20.
Most of the AR-15 news this month has been about paperwork: who is still a plaintiff, whose declaration counts. This brief is the opposite. It is the challengers’ whole case, boiled down to one reply on the only question the Court agreed to answer, and it is the clearest preview yet of what December 2 will sound like.
Deals of the Day
Today's best discounts · Updated 3x daily
Gun Deals
See All →Ammo Deals
See All →Table of Contents
What the Final AR-15 Brief Tells the Supreme Court
The reply brief was submitted on November 20, 2026, under counsel of record David H. Thompson of Cooper & Kirk, who represents the petitioners in both cases. It answers the merits briefs Cook County and Connecticut filed in October.
The opening paragraph is the whole pitch. Heller, it says, “concerned a ban on possession of a class of firearms, focused on the historical tradition of dangerous and unusual weapons, and held that the class of firearms at issue could not be banned because they were in common use.” Then: “No more need be said to resolve this case in Petitioners’ favor.”
The flip side is aimed straight at the justices. According to the reply, “it is not possible for this Court to affirm without overruling the core holdings of Heller and Bruen.” The line I expect to hear again on December 2 comes a page later: “This Court need break no new ground to rule for Petitioners.”
Common Use vs Unusually Dangerous: The Two Tests on the Table
The challengers’ test comes straight from Heller, which held, as the reply quotes it, that “the sorts of weapons protected were those in common use.” The bans’ defenders say arms in common use can still be regulated. The reply’s answer is one sentence long: “But they are immune from categorical prohibition.”
The other side’s test is different in kind. Cook County’s merits brief, signed by State’s Attorney Eileen O’Neill Burke, says “Bans are appropriate when weapons are especially dangerous and not proportional to the end of self-defense.” Connecticut’s brief, with Elizabeth B. Prelogar of Cooley LLP as counsel of record, argues that “AR-15s are unusually dangerous compared to their contemporary peers.”
Connecticut also says the challengers’ rule would freeze the law in place: Congress banned AR-15s in 1994, let the ban lapse in 2004, and on this theory can never act again. “The Second Amendment does not create that one-way ratchet,” the state says. The reply’s answer is that the test asks what is in common use at the time, “so its answer is not fixed forever.”
On whether AR-15s clear the bar, the reply barely breaks a sweat. It reminds the Court that last year, in the Smith & Wesson case brought by Mexico, the justices unanimously described the banned rifles as “both widely legal and bought by many ordinary consumers,” and called the AR-15 “the most popular rifle in the country.” Then the jab: “Respondents do not explain how such firearms could fail to be in common use.”
Why the Reply Calls the Danger Test Interest Balancing
This is the heart of the brief. Bruen ruled out “independent means-end scrutiny under the guise of an analogical inquiry,” and the reply says the danger test is exactly that. Asking whether a rifle is “especially dangerous,” it says, “is no different from asking whether the government has a compelling or substantial interest,” and asking about proportionality “is no different from asking whether a ban is tailored to that interest.”
It goes further. The respondents’ approach “closely mirrors Justice Breyer’s Heller dissent,” the reply says, and it lines their arguments up against the appeals court decisions that upheld rifle bans under intermediate scrutiny before Bruen, including Kolbe v. Hogan from the Fourth Circuit. Comparing a party to a Breyer dissent at this Court is not a compliment.
Then the numbers. The reply says the criminal misuse of handguns “is orders of magnitude greater than the criminal misuse of the banned rifles,” and cites a RAND finding that handguns “are the firearm most commonly involved in” mass shootings. It closes the point with a 2011 D.C. Circuit dissent by then-Judge Brett Kavanaugh, now a justice: “handguns are the quintessential ‘assault weapons’ in today’s society.”
On self-defense, the respondents argue rifles show up in a small share of defensive gun uses. The reply cites a survey by Professor William English finding that “16.4% of defensive gun uses involved rifles,” and adds that owning one counts anyway, quoting Bruen: “Individuals often ‘keep’ firearms in their home, at the ready for self-defense.” Anybody who keeps an AR-15 for home defense already knows that one.
And one footnote for the gun nerds. The opening brief ran a picture of a “Winchester 1873” from a firearms law textbook, and the reply concedes “That rifle may actually be a Winchester 1894.” The difference, it adds, “is immaterial for present purposes.”
The Viramontes Mootness Fight Is Still Undecided
But the Illinois half of the case still has a question mark on it. Cutberto Viramontes asked to be dismissed from the case on October 29, Cook County filed a suggestion of mootness on November 5, the challengers answered on November 11 with two new declarations, and the county replied on November 13 asking the justices to ignore them.
As of the November 20 entries on the Supreme Court docket, the Court had not ruled on the Viramontes motion or the suggestion of mootness. The reply brief does not mention mootness at all. It argues the merits, full stop.
Either way, the AR-15 question survives. Cook County’s own mootness reply says “The parties agree that nothing in this briefing would affect the grant of certiorari in Grant v. Higgins, No. 25-566,” the Connecticut case.
If the justices drop the Illinois case, Connecticut’s statewide ban carries the question alone. If they keep both, they hear a county ordinance and a state law side by side.
What the Justices Will Decide at the AR-15 Supreme Court Argument
The question presented, word for word: “Whether the Second and Fourteenth Amendments guarantee the right to possess AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles.” The Court granted review on June 30, 2026, consolidated the two cases and allotted a total of one hour for argument.
Three sides will get time at the lectern. On November 9 the Court granted the Solicitor General’s motion to take part in argument as amicus curiae, and that motion, filed for a United States that supports the challengers, asked for 20 minutes for petitioners, 10 for the United States and 30 for respondents.
If the Court takes the reply’s route, the case comes down to a popularity question the brief says the justices already answered last year. If it takes the states’ route, judges get a new test that asks how dangerous a rifle is. I do not think the danger test survives the Court that wrote Bruen, and the reply was written to make sure it doesn’t.
Nothing changes for gun owners before a ruling. Cook County’s ordinance and Connecticut’s ban stay on the books, with state rules on top, covered in our Illinois gun laws guide. The briefs are done. The paperwork fight isn’t. On December 2, the rifle finally gets its hearing.
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the AR-15 Supreme Court argument?
Wednesday, December 2, 2026. Viramontes v. Cook County, No. 25-238, and Grant v. Higgins, No. 25-566, are consolidated, and the Court allotted a total of one hour for argument.
What question is the Supreme Court deciding in the AR-15 case?
"Whether the Second and Fourteenth Amendments guarantee the right to possess AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles." The Court agreed to decide it on June 30, 2026.
What is the common-use test?
It comes from District of Columbia v. Heller, which held that "the sorts of weapons protected were those in common use." The challengers argue that arms in common use cannot be banned outright, and that the AR-15 is one of them.
What is the unusually dangerous weapons test?
It is the test Cook County and Connecticut ask the Court to adopt. Cook County's brief says bans are appropriate when weapons are especially dangerous and not proportional to the end of self-defense. The challengers say that is the interest balancing Bruen rejected.
Is the United States taking a side in the AR-15 case?
Yes. The United States filed an amicus brief supporting the challengers, and on November 9, 2026 the Court granted the Solicitor General leave to take part in oral argument.
Could the Supreme Court dismiss the AR-15 case as moot?
Cook County asked the Court to dismiss the Illinois case after Cutberto Viramontes moved to leave it. As of the November 20, 2026 docket entries, the Court had not ruled. The parties agree the mootness briefing would not affect Grant v. Higgins, the Connecticut case, which presents the same question.
Are the Cook County and Connecticut AR-15 bans still in effect?
Yes. The federal appeals courts below ruled against the challengers in both cases, and the bans stay in force unless the Supreme Court rules otherwise.
Related Reading
- Supreme Court Takes the AR-15 Question Head On
- Cook County and Connecticut Defend AR-15 Bans at SCOTUS
- 18 States and DC Back AR-15 Bans at the Supreme Court
- Cook County Asks SCOTUS to Toss the AR-15 Case as Moot
- Viramontes Petitioners Tell SCOTUS AR-15 Case Isn’t Moot
- Connecticut Gun Laws: Permits, Carry Rules and Restrictions
3,170+ Gun & Ammo Deals
Updated daily from 200+ top retailers. Filter by category, caliber, action type, and price.
Related Guides
























