LIVE

Ninth Circuit Revives CCW Suit Over Biker Club Membership

Last updated November 2026 · By Nick Hall, tracks federal and state firearms policy daily for USA Gun Shop readers, with a running file on California’s post-Bruen carry rules

Quick take: The Ninth Circuit on November 20, 2026 revived Kenneth Shilling’s lawsuit against San Diego County, whose sheriff pulled his concealed carry license in December 2023 because he belongs to the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club. The panel also held that California sheriffs are not arms of the state, which knocks out the immunity defense that got his case tossed.

  • Ruling: The panel reversed the dismissal of Shilling’s First Amendment free-association claim, held his Second Amendment claim for injunctive relief is not moot, and sent the case back.
  • Court: Judges Kenneth K. Lee, Patrick J. Bumatay and Jennifer Sung decided case No. 25-291, with Bumatay writing and no judge writing separately.
  • Why it matters: San Diego County can now be held liable under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for the revocation, and the sheriff gets no Eleventh Amendment immunity.
  • What’s next: Unless the county seeks rehearing, the case returns to District Judge Cathy Ann Bencivengo in the Southern District of California for further proceedings.

Most California carry fights since Bruen are about money and paperwork, like the Justice Department’s suit over Glendale’s carry fee. This one is about who you ride with. A permit holder with no criminal record lost his license over a motorcycle club, and the Ninth Circuit just said that story is enough to get him into court.

Deals of the Day

Today's best discounts · Updated 3x daily

Gun Deals

See All →
1 / 10

Ammo Deals

See All →
1 / 10
Table of Contents

How the Boozefighters Cost Kenneth Shilling His CCW

Kenneth Charles Shilling lives in San Diego. In June 2022, while California still had its “good moral character” requirement, he applied for and got a CCW license from then-Sheriff Anthony Ray. The opinion’s next line is dry: “This was short lived.”

In December 2023, Sheriff Kelly Martinez revoked it. Her letter said her office had “received information that [he was] involved with the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club,” called the club a “criminal street gang,” and said that “based on the seriousness of this information,” his CCW had been revoked.

The tool was the department’s own definition of good moral character, which excluded anyone with “a pattern of or propensity for criminal conduct,” including “a close nexus to a criminal gang.” Shilling has no criminal history, according to the opinion. He wasn’t given a chance to contest the allegations before the revocation, though he could ask for reconsideration.

According to Shilling, the Boozefighters were founded in 1946 by World War II veterans and focus on charitable work. That is his allegation. No court has tested it yet.

He sued the county and the sheriff, in her official capacity, under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, claiming the revocation violated his First Amendment right of free association and his Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms. He asked for damages, injunctive relief and destruction of his revocation records. District Judge Cathy Ann Bencivengo threw the case out in pieces.

Four Questions, Four Losses for the District Court

Judge Bumatay framed the appeal as four questions in the published opinion, argued May 20, 2026 in Pasadena and filed November 20. The district court had held the sheriff immune, the county the wrong defendant, the Second Amendment claim moot and the First Amendment claim not pleaded. The panel reversed on all four.

First, the San Diego County Sheriff is not an “arm of the state,” so she is not entitled to Eleventh Amendment immunity. Second, revoking a CCW under the old good moral character test was a county policy, so the county can be held liable under § 1983.

Third, the Second Amendment claim survives, but only partly. The license has since expired and the new 2024 law is in place, so the panel agreed his requests to get the license back and to bar future revocations without proof of a crime are moot, while his request to destroy the revocation records is still alive because, in Shilling’s view, those records “may show up in criminal background checks” and could hurt a future application.

Fourth, the First Amendment claim was adequately pleaded. The panel also brushed aside the county’s fallback argument that the dismissal should stand as a Rule 41(b) sanction, since the judge only granted leave to amend and never ordered an amended complaint.

Why Not an Arm of the State Is the Whole Ballgame

Sovereign immunity in the Ninth Circuit starts with Kohn v. State Bar of California, the 2023 en banc case, as refined this year in Nilsen v. University of Washington after the Supreme Court’s Galette v. New Jersey Transit decision.

Three factors: whether the state built the entity as legally independent, whether the state is formally liable for its judgments, and how much control the state has. The first counts most.

California lost on the first two. The state constitution makes the sheriff an elected county officer, and under California Government Code § 815.2, damages for § 1983 claims against a sheriff are paid by the county, not the state. The Attorney General’s supervision of sheriffs is “nontrivial,” the panel said, but not enough to change the answer.

Here’s the part that travels. The test is entity-based, and the court quoted Kohn that “[A]n entity either is or is not an arm of the state.” The opinion’s conclusion speaks to “California sheriffs” as a class, which makes this a headache for every sheriff’s office in the state facing a federal civil rights suit, not only the CCW ones.

But immunity alone doesn’t put the county on the hook. That takes Monell, the rule that a county pays only for its own policy. Under the old “may issue” law, then-§ 26150 never defined good moral character, so sheriffs did. “No state law mandated this County-specific definition,” the panel wrote, so the county “made association with the Boozefighters a basis to revoke a CCW license.”

The Boozefighters Free-Association Frame

The First Amendment section rests on old civil rights cases, Healy v. James from 1972 and NAACP v. Claiborne Hardware from 1982, plus the Supreme Court’s 2026 First Choice Women’s Resource Centers decision. To take away a benefit over membership in an allegedly criminal group, the government must “establish that the group itself possessed unlawful goals and that the individual held a specific intent to further those illegal aims.”

That burden sits on the sheriff, not on Shilling. And on the facts he pleaded, the panel wasn’t close: “Shilling easily pleaded a violation of his freedom of association.”

The district court had required him to show the revocation stopped him from associating with the club. Wrong test, the panel said. Alleging a penalty for the association itself is enough, and it quoted Healy that “guilt by association alone, without establishing that an individual’s association poses the threat feared by the Government, is an impermissible basis upon which to deny First Amendment rights.”

I do not expect that line to stay in a biker case. Any California applicant denied over who they know rather than what they did now has a published Ninth Circuit opinion to cite.

What the Ninth Circuit Did Not Decide

Nobody won on the merits. This was an appeal from a motion to dismiss, so the panel took Shilling’s allegations as true. It made no finding that the Boozefighters are, or aren’t, a criminal street gang.

The Second Amendment holding is about mootness only. The panel wrote “Assuming a violation of his Second Amendment right” and remanded that claim. It did not rule that the revocation violated the Second Amendment, and it did not order his license returned.

It also didn’t touch the constitutionality of California’s current carry law, and it skipped Shilling’s argument that the State of California should have been joined as a party. The county can still ask for rehearing. As of the November 20 filing, the opinion is the latest word.

SB 2 Already Buried Good Moral Character

The standard Martinez used is gone. Senate Bill 2, Chapter 249 of the Statutes of 2023, was approved by the governor on September 26, 2023 and took effect January 1, 2024, a few weeks after Shilling lost his license. Per the Legislative Counsel’s Digest, it would “remove the good character and good cause requirements from the issuance criteria.”

Now the licensing authority has to issue to qualified applicants who are at least 21 and not a “disqualified person,” which includes anyone “reasonably likely to be a danger to self, others, or the community at large.” If a license is denied or revoked on that basis, the applicant gets 30 days from the notice, or from losing any local appeal the sheriff requires, to request a hearing in superior court. That is a process Shilling never had. It is all laid out in our California gun laws guide, and the history behind it sits in the Bruen decision that forced the rewrite.

Shilling hasn’t won anything yet. He has his day in court back. And the county, not Sacramento, is the one answering for it.


Frequently Asked Questions

What is Shilling v. County of San Diego?

It is a federal lawsuit by Kenneth Shilling, whose San Diego County CCW license was revoked in December 2023 over his membership in the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club. On November 20, 2026 a Ninth Circuit panel reversed the dismissal of his case and sent it back to the district court.

Did the Ninth Circuit rule that Shilling's Second Amendment rights were violated?

No. The panel only held that his Second Amendment claim for injunctive and declaratory relief is not moot, because a court could still order his revocation records destroyed. Whether the revocation violated the Second Amendment is for the district court to decide on remand.

Are California sheriffs arms of the state?

Not for Eleventh Amendment purposes, according to the Ninth Circuit. The panel found California law creates the sheriff as a county officer, the county pays judgments against the sheriff, and state supervision is not enough to change that, so sheriffs do not get state sovereign immunity in federal court.

Can a California sheriff still deny a CCW for lack of good moral character?

No. Senate Bill 2 removed the good moral character and good cause requirements effective January 1, 2024. A sheriff must now issue a license to an applicant who is at least 21, meets the other statutory requirements, and is not a disqualified person under Penal Code section 26202.

Can a CCW be revoked just because of club membership?

The Ninth Circuit said that revoking a license solely over association with a group, with no evidence of wrongdoing, states a First Amendment claim. Under the cases it applied, the government has to show the group had unlawful goals and the person specifically intended to further them.

What can a California applicant do if a CCW is denied or revoked as a disqualified person?

Under Penal Code section 26206, added by Senate Bill 2, the licensing authority must state the reason, and the applicant has 30 days after receiving the notice (or after losing any local appeal the sheriff requires) to request a hearing in the superior court of their county of residence.

Does the Shilling ruling apply outside California?

The free-association holding is published Ninth Circuit precedent, so federal courts across the circuit must follow it. The sheriff immunity and county policy holdings rest on California's constitution and statutes, so they speak to California sheriffs.


3,170+ Gun & Ammo Deals

Updated daily from 200+ top retailers. Filter by category, caliber, action type, and price.

More Gun News

See all news →
West facade of the US Supreme Court building, where Cook County wants the AR-15 case dismissed as moot

AR-15 Supreme Court Argument: Challengers File Final Brief

Nov 20
Two boxes of Barnes Steward Collection ammo with coyote art, one labeled 223 Remington 55gr TVK with a Sierra bullet

Barnes Steward Collection: Varmint Ammo in 9 Calibers

Nov 20
The Iowa State Capitol in Des Moines. Iowa is one of 11 states Operation NFA names for its first legislative push

GOA, Silencer Shop Launch Operation NFA in 11 States

Nov 19
SIG Sauer P385 9mm striker-fired pistol in black, left side, SIG product photo

SIG Sauer P385: A New 9mm That Runs P320 Magazines

Nov 19

Leave a Comment

Scroll back to top

The week's best gun and ammo deals, in one email

Picked from the 200+ retailers we track. Free, one email a week.