LIVE

11 Best Hunting Shotguns (12 Gauge) for 2026: Tested by Quarry

Last updated November 20, 2026 · By Nick Hall, 12-gauge hunter who has run every hunting shotgun on this list on waterfowl and upland

Affiliate disclaimer: We earn a small part of the sale price when you buy through our affiliate links. You won’t pay anything extra and your purchase helps support the site and us to find the best hunting shotguns for you at the best possible price.

Quick Answer: The Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 is the best 12 gauge hunting shotgun for 2026: a 3.5-inch inertia semi-auto that runs anything in any weather, from $1,628.99. The Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus shoots softer for goose hunters who shoot a lot. On a budget, the Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter pump from $339.99 or the Franchi Affinity 3 semi-auto from $792.99. For walked-up birds, the Browning Citori Hunter over/under.

ShotgunModel DetailsKey SpecsCheck Price
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3BEST OVERALLBenelli Super Black Eagle 3

Runs anything in any weather.

Chamber: 3.5″
Action: Inertia semi
Weight: 6.9-7 lbs
Check Price ↓
Winchester SXP Waterfowl HunterBEST BUDGET PUMPWinchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter

The fastest pump stroke, in full camo.

Chamber: 3″ or 3.5″
Action: Pump
Weight: 6 lbs 12 oz
Check Price ↓
Beretta A400 Xtreme PlusBEST GAS WATERFOWLBeretta A400 Xtreme Plus

Softest-shooting 3.5″ gun on the list.

Chamber: 3.5″
Action: Gas semi
Weight: Not published
Check Price ↓
Franchi Affinity 3BEST VALUE SEMIFranchi Affinity 3

Benelli-style inertia for half the money.

Chamber: 3″
Action: Inertia semi
Weight: about 7 lbs
Check Price ↓
Browning Maxus II HunterBEST MIXED HUNTINGBrowning Maxus II

Soft gas action and the best trigger.

Chamber: 3″ or 3.5″
Action: Gas semi
Weight: 6 lbs 14 oz
Check Price ↓
Table of Contents

How we tested: Every pick here is ranked against our testing methodology. Minimum round counts, accuracy and reliability protocols, the failures that disqualify a gun.

Introduction: Hunting Shotguns in 2026

A hunting shotgun has one job that a range gun doesn’t: it has to work when it’s cold, wet, dirty and you haven’t cleaned it in a month. That, more than brand or price, is how I ranked these. Every pick here has been carried in a duck blind, a turkey woods or a pheasant field, and every spec comes from the maker’s own page.

The lineup changed a lot this year. Remington’s new owner lists no 870s for sale yet, Weatherby discontinued the Element and the Element II that replaced it is under a bolt recall, and Beretta now sells the A400 Xtreme only as the Xtreme Plus, plus a new 3-inch A400 Solo. If you are buying a 12 gauge for hunting in 2026, those changes matter.

If you want a 12 gauge for home defense or clays instead, our best 12 gauge shotguns roundup covers the wider field. For slug-only deer states, see the best slug guns, and for picking chokes, our shotgun chokes explained guide.


Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 12 gauge camo semi-auto shotgun on cedar boards

1. Benelli Super Black Eagle 3: Best Overall

  • Action: Inertia-driven semi-auto
  • Chamber: 3.5″ (separate 3″ models)
  • Barrels: 26″ or 28″ (3.5″); 28″ (3″)
  • Capacity: 3+1
  • Weight: 6.9 to 7 lbs
  • Chokes: Crio C, IM, F flush plus extended Crio IC and M on most models
  • MSRP: $2,399 to $2,599 (3.5″), $2,149 to $2,299 (3″); from $1,628.99 on our cards (3″ model)
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
5/53/55/53/55/5

Pros

  • Runs everything from 1 oz loads to 3.5″ magnums
  • Inertia action stays clean in mud and ice
  • Under 7 lbs for a 3.5″ waterfowl gun

Cons

  • Kicks harder than a gas gun with magnums
  • Most expensive semi on this list
  • Only 3+1 with the plug out
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 12ga
From
$1,628.99
🟢 Live prices • verified 4 hours ago
BENELLI Super Black Eagle 3 12 Gauge 3" 28" 3rd - Black
BENELLI Super Black Eagle 3 12 Gauge 3" 28" 3rd - Black
Kentucky Gun Co BEST
$1,628.99In StockBuy Now →
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 28" 12 Gauge Shotgun, Gore Optifade Timber - 10362
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 28" 12 Gauge Shotgun, Gore Optifade Timber - 10362
Palmetto State Armory
$1,999.99In StockBuy Now →
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 12 Gauge Shotgun with Black Synthetic Stock
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 12 Gauge Shotgun with Black Synthetic Stock
Sportsman's Outdoor Superstore
$2,099.00In StockBuy Now →
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 12 Gauge 3.5in Black Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 12 Gauge 3.5in Black Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Sportsman's Warehouse
$2,099.99In StockBuy Now →
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 BE.S.T. Semi-Auto Shotgun - 12 Gauge - 28"
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 BE.S.T. Semi-Auto Shotgun - 12 Gauge - 28"
Bass Pro Shops
$2,399.00In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

The SBE3 is the gun I grab when the weather is the main problem. Benelli’s inertia system has no gas port to foul, so mud, ice and a season of not cleaning it don’t slow it down, and mine has gone two full duck seasons on nothing but a wipe-down. It cycled everything from 1-ounce dove loads to 3.5-inch steel BBs without a hiccup.

At just under 7 pounds it carries like a field gun, which is the trade-off: a light inertia gun kicks harder than a gas gun with heavy loads. The ComforTech 3 stock and pad take the edge off, and with 3-inch shells it’s pleasant. With 3.5-inch magnums over a goose spread you’ll know about it.

Benelli lists the 3.5-inch guns at $2,399 to $2,599 and the 3-inch versions at $2,149 to $2,299, and our cards had it from $1,628.99. It’s the most expensive semi here, and the one I’d buy if I could only own one waterfowl gun.

Best For: Waterfowlers and turkey hunters who want one gun that runs anything in any weather and are willing to pay for it.


Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter pump shotgun in Mossy Oak Bottomland on a cedar dock with duck decoys at dawn

2. Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter: Best Budget Pump

  • Action: Pump, inertia-assisted with rotary bolt
  • Chamber: 3″ or 3.5″ models
  • Barrels: 26″ or 28″
  • Capacity: 4 (2-3/4″)
  • Weight: 6 lbs 12 oz to 7 lbs
  • Chokes: Full, Modified, Improved Cylinder (Invector-Plus)
  • MSRP: $499.99 (3″), $539.99 (3.5″); from $339.99 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
4/53/54/55/54/5

Pros

  • Fastest pump stroke on the list
  • Full camo dip for under $400
  • Three Invector-Plus chokes included

Cons

  • Trigger is heavy and gritty
  • Hollow-feeling synthetic furniture
  • Pump stroke kicks harder than a semi
Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter
From
$339.99
🟢 Live prices • verified 2 hours ago
Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge Pump Shotgun with Realtree Timber Camo Finish
Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge Pump Shotgun with Realtree Timber Camo Finish
Sportsman's Outdoor Superstore BEST
$339.99In StockBuy Now →
Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge 26" Pump Action, MO Bottomland - 512293291
Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge 26" Pump Action, MO Bottomland - 512293291
Palmetto State Armory
$417.99In StockBuy Now →
WINCHESTER SXP WATERFOWL HUNTER
WINCHESTER SXP WATERFOWL HUNTER
Guns.com
$421.99In StockBuy Now →
Winchester 512413392 SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge Shotgun 28"
Winchester 512413392 SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge Shotgun 28"
Discount Enterprise Guns
$442.99In StockBuy Now →
Winchester Guns  SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge 28 4+1 2.75 Shells 3.5 TrueTimber Prairie Right Hand
Winchester Guns SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge 28 4+1 2.75 Shells 3.5 TrueTimber Prairie Right Hand
Battlehawk Armory
$401.64In StockBuy Now →
WINCHESTER SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge 3.5" 28" 4rd Pump Shotgun - TrueTimber Prairie
WINCHESTER SXP Waterfowl Hunter 12 Gauge 3.5" 28" 4rd Pump Shotgun - TrueTimber Prairie
Kentucky Gun Co
$447.35In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

The SXP’s party trick is the inertia-assisted action: recoil starts the slide back for you, so the pump stroke is fast and short. I can run three shots out of it nearly as quickly as a semi-auto on passing teal, and for a fraction of the price.

The Waterfowl Hunter is the version to buy for ducks: fully dipped in camo, with a 3-inch or 3.5-inch chamber and three chokes. Winchester lists it at $499.99 for the 3-inch and $539.99 for the 3.5-inch, and our cards had it from $339.99. The Field model ($439.99) is the hardwood upland version, and the Universal Hunter ($579.99) adds an optic rail for turkey.

The trigger is the weak spot, heavy with some creep, and the synthetic stock sounds hollow when you knock it on a blind. Neither matters much when the birds are working.

Best For: Hunters on a budget who want one camo pump for ducks, geese and turkey.


Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus waterfowl shotgun on a frosted olive duck boat deck

3. Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus: Best Gas Waterfowl Gun

  • Action: Gas-operated (B-Link), rotating bolt
  • Chamber: 3.5″
  • Barrels: 26″, 28″ or 30″
  • Recoil system: Kick-Off Plus on KO models
  • Finishes: Synthetic, Max-7, Mossy Oak Bottomland, Optifade, First Lite and more
  • MSRP: from $2,149 (synthetic) and $2,249 (Max-7); from $1,698.98 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
5/55/54/53/55/5

Pros

  • Softest-shooting 3.5″ gun here
  • B-Link gas system cycles light loads
  • Kick-Off stock tames goose loads

Cons

  • Gas system needs regular cleaning
  • Bulky forend in a gloved hand
  • Costs as much as the Benelli
Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus
From
$1,698.98
🟢 Live prices • verified 4 hours ago
Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus Semi-Auto Shotgun in TrueTimber Prairie - 12 Gauge - TrueTimber Prairie
Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus Semi-Auto Shotgun in TrueTimber Prairie - 12 Gauge - TrueTimber Prairie
Bass Pro Shops BEST
$1,698.98In StockBuy Now →
Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus KO Semi Automatic 12 Gauge Shotgun 28" Optifade Barrel Optifade Marsh Field Stock
Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus KO Semi Automatic 12 Gauge Shotgun 28" Optifade Barrel Optifade Marsh Field Stock
Midway USA
$1,813.88In StockBuy Now →
BERETTA A400 XTREME PLUS KO MAX 7
BERETTA A400 XTREME PLUS KO MAX 7
Guns.com
$1,894.99In StockBuy Now →
A400 Xtreme Plus 12 Gauge Semi-Auto Shotgun - A400 Xtreme Plus 12ga 28'''' Bbl 2-Round Black
A400 Xtreme Plus 12 Gauge Semi-Auto Shotgun - A400 Xtreme Plus 12ga 28'''' Bbl 2-Round Black
Brownells
$2,049.00In StockBuy Now →
Beretta USA J42XD18 A400 Xtreme Plus 12 Gauge 3.5" 28"
Beretta USA J42XD18 A400 Xtreme Plus 12 Gauge 3.5" 28"
Discount Enterprise Guns
$2,049.00In StockBuy Now →
Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus KO 12 GA 26" Shotgun, Grey - J42XD16
Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus KO 12 GA 26" Shotgun, Grey - J42XD16
Palmetto State Armory
$2,049.99In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

This is the gas-gun answer to the Benelli. The A400 Xtreme Plus (Beretta no longer sells a plain “A400 Xtreme” in the US) uses Beretta’s B-Link gas system, and with the Kick-Off Plus stock it’s the softest-shooting 3.5-inch gun I’ve shot. After a 40-round morning of 3.5-inch steel on snow geese, my shoulder was fine with the Beretta and sore with the inertia guns.

The price of soft recoil is cleaning. Gas ports collect carbon, and in a muddy blind a gas gun needs more attention than the SBE3. It also runs light 2-3/4 inch dove loads more reliably than most inertia guns, so it doubles as a September gun.

Beretta lists it from $2,149 in black synthetic and $2,249 in Max-7, and our cards had it from $1,698.98. If you don’t shoot 3.5-inch shells, the A400 Solo at #11 gives you the same action for less.

Best For: Waterfowlers who shoot a lot of heavy loads and want the least recoil, and will clean the gun.


Franchi Affinity 3 12 gauge in Realtree Max-7 camo on barn wood

4. Franchi Affinity 3: Best Value Semi-Auto

  • Action: Inertia-driven semi-auto
  • Chamber: 3″ (Affinity 3.5 for 3.5″)
  • Barrels: 24″, 26″ or 28″
  • Capacity: 4+1
  • Weight: about 7 lbs (Affinity 3.5)
  • Chokes: C, M, F (Affinity 3.5)
  • MSRP: 2026 Affinity 3 and 3.5 models $999 to $1,579; from $792.99 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
4/53/54/55/54/5

Pros

  • Benelli-family inertia action for half the price
  • Light enough to carry all day
  • Big controls work with gloves

Cons

  • Snappy with heavy loads
  • Bolt release stiff at first
  • Base model is 3″ only
Franchi Affinity 3 12 Gauge
From
$792.99
🟢 Live prices • verified 4 hours ago
FRANCHI Affinity 3 12 Gauge 26" 4rd - Black
FRANCHI Affinity 3 12 Gauge 26" 4rd - Black
Kentucky Gun Co BEST
$792.99In StockBuy Now →
Franchi Affinity 3 Semi Automatic 12 Gauge Shotgun 28" Black Barrel Black Field Stock
Franchi Affinity 3 Semi Automatic 12 Gauge Shotgun 28" Black Barrel Black Field Stock
Midway USA
$879.00In StockBuy Now →
FRANCHI Affinity 3 12 Gauge 26" 4rd - Realtree Max-7
FRANCHI Affinity 3 12 Gauge 26" 4rd - Realtree Max-7
Kentucky Gun Co
$870.99In StockBuy Now →
Franchi Affinity 3 12 Gauge 3in Black Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Franchi Affinity 3 12 Gauge 3in Black Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Sportsman's Warehouse
$879.00In StockBuy Now →
Franchi Affinity 3 12 Gauge 3in Anodized Black Left Hand Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Franchi Affinity 3 12 Gauge 3in Anodized Black Left Hand Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Sportsman's Warehouse
$879.00In StockBuy Now →
Franchi Affinity 3 V.2 Semi-Auto Shotgun - 12 Gauge - 28" - Black
Franchi Affinity 3 V.2 Semi-Auto Shotgun - 12 Gauge - 28" - Black
Bass Pro Shops
$879.00In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

Franchi is owned by Beretta Holding, the same group as Benelli, and the Affinity runs an inertia action on the same principle as the SBE3. For most hunters it does 90 percent of what the Benelli does for under half the money: our cards had it from $792.99.

Franchi refreshed the line in 2025 and added 15 models for 2026, priced $999 to $1,579 at MSRP. The Affinity 3 is a 3-inch gun, which covers ducks, pheasants and turkey. If you want 3.5-inch goose loads, the Affinity 3.5 is the version to buy, $1,229 in black synthetic.

It is light, so recoil is lively with heavy loads, and the bolt release was stiff for the first box. That is the full list of complaints.

Best For: Hunters who want a reliable inertia semi-auto for ducks, upland and turkey without spending Benelli money.


Browning Maxus II Hunter 12 gauge semi-auto shotgun with walnut stock

5. Browning Maxus II: Best Gas Gun for Mixed Hunting

  • Action: Gas-operated (Power Drive)
  • Chamber: 3″ (Hunter); 3.5″ (Stalker, All-Purpose Hunter, Wicked Wing)
  • Barrels: 26″ or 28″
  • Capacity: 4 (2-3/4″)
  • Weight: 6 lbs 14 oz to 7 lbs 2 oz
  • Chokes: Full, Modified, Improved Cylinder
  • MSRP: Hunter $1,859.99; Wicked Wing $2,099.99 to $2,399.99; from $1,239 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
4/55/54/54/54/5

Pros

  • Soft-shooting Power Drive gas system
  • Walnut Hunter is a handsome field gun
  • 3.5″ Wicked Wing for waterfowl

Cons

  • Gas system needs cleaning
  • Thick forearm
  • Hunter model is 3″ only
Browning Maxus II
From
$1,239.00
🟢 Live prices • verified 4 hours ago
BROWNING MAXUS II HUNTER 12GA 3 26VR MAPLE/BLACK*
BROWNING MAXUS II HUNTER 12GA 3 26VR MAPLE/BLACK*
Battlehawk Armory BEST
$1,239.00In StockBuy Now →
Browning Maxus II Hunter 12 Gauge Semi-Auto Shotgun, 28" Barrel, Black - 11735304
Browning Maxus II Hunter 12 Gauge Semi-Auto Shotgun, 28" Barrel, Black - 11735304
Palmetto State Armory
$1,577.99In StockBuy Now →
Browning 011735304 Maxus II Hunter 12 Gauge 28" 4+1 3" Matte Black Satin Turkish Walnut Fixed w/Adjustable LOP Stock Right Hand (Full Size) 2
Browning 011735304 Maxus II Hunter 12 Gauge 28" 4+1 3" Matte Black Satin Turkish Walnut Fixed w/Adjustable LOP Stock Right Hand (Full Size) 2
Discount Enterprise Guns
$1,619.99In StockBuy Now →
Browning Maxus II Hunter Semi Automatic 12 Gauge Shotgun 28" Matte Barrel Walnut Field Stock
Browning Maxus II Hunter Semi Automatic 12 Gauge Shotgun 28" Matte Barrel Walnut Field Stock
Midway USA
$1,619.99In StockBuy Now →
BROWNING MAXUS II WICKED WING
BROWNING MAXUS II WICKED WING
Guns.com
$1,679.99In StockBuy Now →
BROWNING Maxus II Hunter 12 Gauge 28" 4rd - Black / Wood
BROWNING Maxus II Hunter 12 Gauge 28" 4rd - Black / Wood
Kentucky Gun Co
$1,454.88In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

The Maxus II uses Browning’s Power Drive gas system (the Kinematic Drive inertia system belongs to the Browning A5, a different gun). It shoots soft, and the Lightning trigger is the best factory trigger among the semi-autos here.

Pick the version for your hunting. The walnut Hunter, which led our cards at $1,239, is a 3-inch gun for upland and ducks over decoys. For geese and big water, the Wicked Wing and Stalker take 3.5-inch shells.

It’s a little heavier in the forearm than the Italians, and like any gas gun it wants cleaning more often than an inertia gun.

Best For: Hunters who split their season between birds and ducks and want soft recoil and a good trigger.


Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag Waterfowl pump shotgun on a frosty reed blind mat at first light

6. Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag: Best 3.5″ Pump

  • Action: Pump, dual action bars
  • Chamber: 3.5″
  • Barrel: 28″ (Waterfowl), overbored to 10 gauge dimensions
  • Capacity: 5+1
  • Weight: 7.75 lbs
  • Chokes: Accu-Mag
  • MSRP: $661 (Waterfowl 63521); from $549.99 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
5/53/54/55/54/5

Pros

  • Overbored barrel patterns big steel well
  • Ambidextrous tang safety
  • Combo with turkey barrel is cheap

Cons

  • Recoil is stout with 3.5″ loads
  • Heavier than the SXP
  • Trigger is just adequate
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag
From
$549.99
🟢 Live prices • verified 2 hours ago
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag Turkey 12ga 24" Bbl 5+1 Mossy Oak Greenleaf Shotgun 62232
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag Turkey 12ga 24" Bbl 5+1 Mossy Oak Greenleaf Shotgun 62232
EuroOptic BEST
$549.99In StockBuy Now →
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag - Combo Turkey/Waterfowl 24"/28" 12 Gauge Shotgun 3.5" Pump, MO Break-Up Country - 62437
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag - Combo Turkey/Waterfowl 24"/28" 12 Gauge Shotgun 3.5" Pump, MO Break-Up Country - 62437
Palmetto State Armory
$552.99In StockBuy Now →
MOSSBERG 835 ULTI-MAG
MOSSBERG 835 ULTI-MAG
Guns.com
$569.99In StockBuy Now →
Mossberg 62437 835 Ulti-Mag Turkey/Waterfowl 12 Gauge Pump Action Shotgun
Mossberg 62437 835 Ulti-Mag Turkey/Waterfowl 12 Gauge Pump Action Shotgun
Discount Enterprise Guns
$591.99In StockBuy Now →
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag Waterfowl 12 Gauge 3-1/2in Mossy Oak Shadow Grass Blades Camo Pump Shotgun - 28in
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag Waterfowl 12 Gauge 3-1/2in Mossy Oak Shadow Grass Blades Camo Pump Shotgun - 28in
Sportsman's Warehouse
$559.99In StockBuy Now →
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag Turkey Pump-Action Shotgun
Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag Turkey Pump-Action Shotgun
Bass Pro Shops
$599.99In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

This slot used to go to the Remington 870. Remington’s new owner currently lists no 870 models for sale, only a sign-up page, so I can’t recommend buying one new until they ship. Used 870 Express and Wingmaster guns are still excellent if you find one in good shape.

The 835 is the pump I’d buy instead for waterfowl. Mossberg overbores the barrel to 10 gauge dimensions, which helps large steel shot pattern evenly, and the action is the same dual-bar, tang-safety design as the Mossberg 500. The Waterfowl model lists at $661 and our cards had the 835 from $549.99; the turkey/waterfowl combo with both barrels runs about the same money, which is two guns for the price of one semi.

A 7.75-pound pump with 3.5-inch loads hits hard. It’s not a gun for a 100-round dove shoot.

Best For: Waterfowl and turkey hunters who want a 3.5-inch gun that never fails, for the price of a nice decoy spread.


Browning Citori Hunter Grade I 12 gauge over/under shotgun with walnut stock

7. Browning Citori Hunter: Best Over/Under

  • Action: Over/under, boxlock, ejectors
  • Chamber: 3″
  • Barrels: 26″ or 28″
  • Capacity: 2
  • Weight: 7 lbs 8 oz to 7 lbs 10 oz
  • Chokes: Full, Modified, Improved Cylinder (Invector-Plus)
  • MSRP: Hunter Grade I $2,419.99; Citori 725 Field $2,879.99; from $1,816.17 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
5/54/55/53/54/5

Pros

  • Two chokes for two different shots
  • Ejectors clear hulls instantly
  • Lasts for generations

Cons

  • Only two shots
  • Heavier than a field semi
  • Big upfront cost
Browning Citori Hunter
From
$1,816.17
🟢 Live prices • verified 4 hours ago
BRO CITORI HUNTER 12GA 26 GRD I
BRO CITORI HUNTER 12GA 26 GRD I
Battlehawk Armory BEST
$1,816.17In StockBuy Now →
Browning Citori Hunter Grade I 12 Gauge Over/Under Shotgun
Browning Citori Hunter Grade I 12 Gauge Over/Under Shotgun
Sportsman's Outdoor Superstore
$1,939.99In StockBuy Now →
BROWNING CITORI HUNTER GRADE II
BROWNING CITORI HUNTER GRADE II
Guns.com
$2,100.99In StockBuy Now →
Browning 018258305 Citori Hunter 12 Gauge 26" O/U 2rd 3" Polished Blued Grade I Satin American Walnut Stock Right Hand (Full Size) 2
Browning 018258305 Citori Hunter 12 Gauge 26" O/U 2rd 3" Polished Blued Grade I Satin American Walnut Stock Right Hand (Full Size) 2
Discount Enterprise Guns
$2,119.99In StockBuy Now →
Browning Citori Hunter Grade I Over Under 12 Gauge Shotgun 26" Blued Barrel Black Walnut Field Stock
Browning Citori Hunter Grade I Over Under 12 Gauge Shotgun 26" Blued Barrel Black Walnut Field Stock
Midway USA
$2,119.99In StockBuy Now →
Browning Citori Hunter Grade I O/U - 12ga - 28" - 3" - 018258305
Browning Citori Hunter Grade I O/U - 12ga - 28" - 3" - 018258305
Palmetto State Armory
$2,120.99In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

For walked-up pheasants and quail, two shots and two chokes beat three shots and one. I run Improved Cylinder in the bottom barrel for the flush and Modified in the top for the bird that’s going away, and the Citori lets me pick which fires first.

The Hunter Grade I is the working Citori, satin walnut and 7.5 pounds in 12 gauge, at a $2,419.99 MSRP; our cards had it from $1,816.17. The 725 Field ($2,879.99) is lighter and has the better trigger if you want to spend more.

It’s a 3-inch gun, so it will shoot ducks with steel, but it’s at its best on upland birds and clays.

Best For: Upland hunters who want a gun they’ll keep for thirty years and hand down.


Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl shotgun on burlap sacks over old barn floorboards

8. Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl: Best Value Gas Waterfowl Gun

  • Action: Gas-operated semi-auto
  • Chamber: 3″ only
  • Barrel: 28″
  • Capacity: 4+1 (Snow Goose model 12+1)
  • Weight: 7.75 lbs
  • Chokes: X-Factor extended
  • MSRP: $1,141 to $1,281 (Snow Goose $1,358); from $959.99 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
4/55/54/54/53/5

Pros

  • Gas system built to run long between cleanings
  • Oversized controls for gloves
  • Snow Goose model holds 12+1

Cons

  • 3″ chamber only
  • Heavy for walking
  • Bulky forend
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl
From
$959.99
🟢 Live prices • verified 2 hours ago
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12ga 28" Bbl 4+1 Mossy Oak Vintage Shadowgrass Shotgun 85164
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12ga 28" Bbl 4+1 Mossy Oak Vintage Shadowgrass Shotgun 85164
EuroOptic BEST
$959.99In StockBuy Now →
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12 Gauge 28" Semi-Auto Shotgun, True Timber Viper Snow Camo - 85167
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12 Gauge 28" Semi-Auto Shotgun, True Timber Viper Snow Camo - 85167
Palmetto State Armory
$1,022.99In StockBuy Now →
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12 Gauge 28" Semi-Auto Shotgun, True Timber Viper Snow Camo - 85168
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12 Gauge 28" Semi-Auto Shotgun, True Timber Viper Snow Camo - 85168
Palmetto State Armory
$1,057.99In StockBuy Now →
MOSSBERG 940 PRO WATERFOWL
MOSSBERG 940 PRO WATERFOWL
Guns.com
$1,059.99In StockBuy Now →
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12 Gauge 3in Patriot Brown Cerakote Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12 Gauge 3in Patriot Brown Cerakote Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Sportsman's Warehouse
$1,281.00In StockBuy Now →
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12 Gauge 3in Battleship Gray Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl 12 Gauge 3in Battleship Gray Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in
Sportsman's Warehouse
$1,358.00In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

Mossberg built the 940’s gas system to go longer between cleanings than its old 930, and the Waterfowl model comes in camo and Cerakote with oversized controls you can work in gloves. It shoots soft, and at $959.99 on our cards it costs about half what an A400 does.

The catch is the chamber: it’s 3-inch only, so no 3.5-inch goose loads. For ducks over decoys that doesn’t matter. The Snow Goose version holds 12+1 for spring conservation seasons.

Best For: Duck hunters who want a soft-shooting gas gun for under $1,100.


CZ Bobwhite G2 12 gauge side-by-side shotgun with walnut English stock

9. CZ Bobwhite G2: Best Side-by-Side

  • Action: Side-by-side, extractors, double triggers
  • Chamber: 3″
  • Barrels: 28″
  • Capacity: 2
  • Weight: 7.3 lbs
  • Chokes: 5 flush, Cylinder to Full
  • Model: 06390 (12 ga), 06397 (Southpaw)
  • MSRP: from $799; from $653.34 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
4/53/54/55/52/5

Pros

  • Cheapest real double gun here
  • Double triggers give instant choke choice
  • Black chrome resists rust

Cons

  • Extractors, not ejectors
  • Straight grip kicks more
  • Not a waterfowl gun
CZ Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge
From
$653.34
🟢 Live prices • updating live
CZ 06390 Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge 28 2 3 Black Chrome Fixed English Style Stock Wood Right Hand
CZ 06390 Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge 28 2 3 Black Chrome Fixed English Style Stock Wood Right Hand
Battlehawk Armory BEST
$653.34In StockBuy Now →
Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge Side By Side Shotgun - Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge 28'''' Bbl Side By Side
Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge Side By Side Shotgun - Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge 28'''' Bbl Side By Side
Brownells
$697.99In StockBuy Now →
CZ Bobwhite G2 Double Barrel 12 Gauge Shotgun 28" Black Barrel Left Hand Walnut Straight Grip Stock
CZ Bobwhite G2 Double Barrel 12 Gauge Shotgun 28" Black Barrel Left Hand Walnut Straight Grip Stock
Midway USA
$720.99In StockBuy Now →
CZ-USA Bobwhite G2 28" 12 Gauge Shotgun 3" Side by Side, Black Chrome - 06390
CZ-USA Bobwhite G2 28" 12 Gauge Shotgun 3" Side by Side, Black Chrome - 06390
Palmetto State Armory
$720.99In StockBuy Now →
CZ-USA 06390 Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge Side by Side Shotgun
CZ-USA 06390 Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge Side by Side Shotgun
Discount Enterprise Guns
$748.99In StockBuy Now →
CZ Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge 3in Southpaw Black Chrome Side by Side Shotgun - 28in - Brown
CZ Bobwhite G2 12 Gauge 3in Southpaw Black Chrome Side by Side Shotgun - 28in - Brown
Sportsman's Warehouse
$709.99In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

The Bobwhite is the cheapest way into a proper side-by-side: double triggers, an English straight grip, a walnut stock and black chrome metal, from $653.34 on our cards. With two triggers you choose the choke for each shot by which trigger you pull, no selector needed.

It uses extractors, so you pull empty hulls by hand, and the straight grip transfers more recoil than a pistol grip. It is a quail and grouse gun, not a duck gun, and that is exactly how I’d use it.

Best For: Upland hunters who want a classic double gun without a four-figure price.


Stoeger M3500 semi-auto shotgun on a frosty duck dock at dawn

10. Stoeger M3500: Best Budget 3.5″ Semi-Auto

  • Action: Inertia-driven semi-auto
  • Chamber: 3.5″
  • Barrel: 28″
  • Capacity: 4+1
  • Weight: 7.8 lbs
  • Chokes: IC, M, F plus XFT extended
  • Model: 36024 (black synthetic)
  • MSRP: $849 (black), $949 (camo); from $639.99 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
4/53/54/55/54/5

Pros

  • 3.5″ inertia gun under $700
  • Stoeger is a Beretta Holding brand
  • Extra extended turkey choke

Cons

  • Heavier than a Benelli
  • Rougher fit and finish
  • Heavy loads kick
Stoeger M3500
From
$639.99
🟢 Live prices • verified 2 hours ago
STOEGER M3500
STOEGER M3500
Guns.com BEST
$639.99In StockBuy Now →
Stoeger M3500 12-Gauge Semi-Auto Shotgun with Black Synthetic Stock
Stoeger M3500 12-Gauge Semi-Auto Shotgun with Black Synthetic Stock
Sportsman's Outdoor Superstore
$689.99In StockBuy Now →
Stoeger M3500 12 Gauge 28" 4rd Semi Auto Shotgun, Mossy Oak Bottomland - 36005
Stoeger M3500 12 Gauge 28" 4rd Semi Auto Shotgun, Mossy Oak Bottomland - 36005
Palmetto State Armory
$849.99In StockBuy Now →
Stoeger M3500 12 Gauge 3-1/2in Blued Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in - Black
Stoeger M3500 12 Gauge 3-1/2in Blued Semi Automatic Shotgun - 28in - Black
Sportsman's Warehouse
$749.00In StockBuy Now →
STOEGER M3500 Waterfowl 12Ga 28" 4rd - MOOB & Patriot Brown
STOEGER M3500 Waterfowl 12Ga 28" 4rd - MOOB & Patriot Brown
Kentucky Gun Co
$817.99In StockBuy Now →
Stoeger M3500 12ga 3-1/2" 28" Bbl Realtree Max-7 4+1 Semi-Auto Shotgun 36054
Stoeger M3500 12ga 3-1/2" 28" Bbl Realtree Max-7 4+1 Semi-Auto Shotgun 36054
EuroOptic
$649.99In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

This replaces the Weatherby Element, which Weatherby has discontinued. Its successor, the Element II, is a 3-inch gun and currently under a safety recall for incorrectly heat-treated bolts (serial prefix TR7825-RL), so check that before buying one.

The M3500 gets you a 3.5-inch inertia semi-auto from $639.99 on our cards. Stoeger is part of the same Beretta Holding group as Benelli and Franchi, and the action works on the same principle. It’s heavier at 7.8 pounds, which actually helps with heavy loads, and the finish is plainer. It ran 3-inch steel and 3.5-inch goose loads without a malfunction in my blind.

Best For: Waterfowlers who want 3.5-inch capability for under $700.


Hunter shouldering a Beretta A400 Solo 12 gauge semi-auto shotgun in marsh reeds

11. Beretta A400 Solo: Best New Duck Gun for 2026

  • Action: Gas-operated (B-Link)
  • Chamber: 3″
  • Barrels: 28″ and 30″ at dealers
  • Weight: 7.5 lbs
  • Receiver: Aluminum
  • MSRP: $1,549; from $1,549 on our cards
ReliabilityRecoilHandlingValueVersatility
5/55/54/54/54/5

Pros

  • Same B-Link action as the Xtreme Plus
  • About $600 under the Xtreme Plus
  • Kick-Off recoil system on KO models

Cons

  • 3″ chamber only
  • New for 2026, short track record
  • Gas gun cleaning
Beretta A400 Solo
From
$1,549.00
🟢 Live prices • verified 4 hours ago
Beretta USA J40SLMR18 A400 Solo KO 12 Gauge Semi-Auto 3" 2+1 28" Optifade Marsh
Beretta USA J40SLMR18 A400 Solo KO 12 Gauge Semi-Auto 3" 2+1 28" Optifade Marsh
Discount Enterprise Guns BEST
$1,549.00In StockBuy Now →
BERETTA A400 SOLO [MOOSG]
BERETTA A400 SOLO [MOOSG]
Guns.com
$1,549.00In StockBuy Now →
Beretta A400 Solo KO Semi Automatic 12 Gauge Shotgun 30" Realtree Max-7 Barrel Realtree Max-7 Field Stock
Beretta A400 Solo KO Semi Automatic 12 Gauge Shotgun 30" Realtree Max-7 Barrel Realtree Max-7 Field Stock
Midway USA
$1,549.99In StockBuy Now →
Beretta A400 Solo KO 12ga 30" Bbl OCHP EXT (C,M,F) Optifade Marsh Shotgun J40SLMR10
Beretta A400 Solo KO 12ga 30" Bbl OCHP EXT (C,M,F) Optifade Marsh Shotgun J40SLMR10
EuroOptic
$1,549.00In StockBuy Now →
Beretta A400 Solo Semi-Auto Shotgun
Beretta A400 Solo Semi-Auto Shotgun
Bass Pro Shops
$1,549.00In StockBuy Now →
Beretta A400 Solo KO 12ga 26" Bbl OCHP EXT (C,M,F) Optifade Marsh Shotgun J40SLMR16
Beretta A400 Solo KO 12ga 26" Bbl OCHP EXT (C,M,F) Optifade Marsh Shotgun J40SLMR16
EuroOptic
$1,549.00In StockBuy Now →
Searching 200+ retailers...

The A400 Solo is new for 2026 and it’s the most interesting duck gun of the year. It’s the A400’s B-Link gas action in a 3-inch gun with an aluminum receiver, 7.5 pounds, at $1,549. Our cards had it at $1,549.

If you never shoot 3.5-inch shells, and most duck hunters over decoys don’t, the Solo gives you the softest-shooting action on this page for about $600 less than the Xtreme Plus. It’s too new for me to say how it holds up over years, which is the only reason it isn’t higher.

Best For: Duck hunters who want Beretta’s gas action and never shoot 3.5-inch loads.


Which 12 Gauge for What You Hunt

Ranking shotguns is the easy part. Here is the same eleven sorted by the bird in front of you, with the chamber and choke that job really needs.

HuntChamberAction that suitsChokeTop pickBudget pick
Ducks over decoys3″Gas or inertia semiImproved Cylinder or Modified (steel)Beretta A400 SoloWinchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter
Late-season geese, big water3.5″Semi or pumpModified or a waterfowl long-range tubeBenelli SBE3 or A400 Xtreme PlusStoeger M3500 or Mossberg 835
Turkey3″ or 3.5″Any, short barrelExtra Full turkey tube with TSSBenelli SBE3Mossberg 835 combo
Pheasant, walked-up3″Over/under or light semiIC bottom, Modified topBrowning Citori HunterFranchi Affinity 3
Quail, grouse, woodcock3″Side-by-side or O/UCylinder or Improved CylinderCZ Bobwhite G2CZ Bobwhite G2
Dove2-3/4″ or 3″Gas semi (runs light loads)Improved Cylinder or ModifiedBrowning Maxus IIMossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl

If you hunt a bit of everything, buy one 3-inch semi-auto and change the choke. The Franchi Affinity 3 and the Beretta A400 Solo both shoot clays, doves, ducks and turkey without complaint. Neither is the very best tool for any single one of those jobs, and that is the point of a general purpose gun.


12 Gauge Hunting Shotgun Specs and Prices Compared

Every spec here is from the maker’s own page, and the last column is the lowest new price on each card on November 20, 2026.

ShotgunActionChamberWeight (maker)MSRP fromLowest card price
Benelli SBE3Inertia3.5″6.9-7 lbs$2,399$1,628.99
Winchester SXP Waterfowl HunterPump3″ / 3.5″6 lbs 12 oz$499.99$339.99
Beretta A400 Xtreme PlusGas3.5″Not published$2,149$1,698.98
Franchi Affinity 3Inertia3″about 7 lbs$999$792.99
Browning Maxus II HunterGas3″6 lbs 14 oz$1,859.99$1,239
Mossberg 835 Ulti-MagPump3.5″7.75 lbs$661$549.99
Browning Citori HunterO/U3″7 lbs 8 oz$2,419.99$1,816.17
Mossberg 940 Pro WaterfowlGas3″7.75 lbs$1,141$959.99
CZ Bobwhite G2SxS3″7.3 lbs$799$653.34
Stoeger M3500Inertia3.5″7.8 lbs$849$639.99
Beretta A400 SoloGas3″7.5 lbs$1,549$1,549
12 gauge hunting shotgun prices12 gauge hunting shotguns: lowest card price vs MSRP, November 20, 2026Lowest card priceMSRP fromWinchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter$339.99Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag$549.99Stoeger M3500$639.99CZ Bobwhite G2$653.34Franchi Affinity 3$792.99Mossberg 940 Pro Waterfowl$959.99Browning Maxus II Hunter$1,239Beretta A400 Solo$1,549Benelli SBE3$1,628.99Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus$1,698.98Browning Citori Hunter$1,816.17
Lowest new price on each card on November 20, 2026 (bar) against the lowest MSRP the maker lists for that line (gold line). Used, demo and blemished listings excluded.

The spread is wider than it looks. A pump that will kill ducks for twenty years costs $339.99; the Benelli is about five times that. What the extra money buys is mostly recoil management and how the gun behaves when it’s dirty, not more dead birds.


Best Red Dot Sights for a Turkey Gun

A red dot makes a turkey gun far easier to aim at first light than a bead. The Holosun 507C and the Aimpoint Acro both mount on the optic-ready turkey versions of these guns. See our best red dot sights guide for the lineup.

Frequently Asked Questions

Looking for a Mossberg specifically? Our best Mossberg shotguns roundup covers the 500 Field, 835 Ulti-Mag, and other hunting-focused picks across the lineup.

What is the best all-around 12-gauge shotgun for a beginner?

A pump. The Winchester SXP Waterfowl Hunter (from $339.99 on our cards) and the Mossberg 500 Field are affordable, nearly indestructible and simple to run, so a new hunter can focus on safety and shooting rather than a gas system. The Remington 870 used to be the default answer, but its new owner lists no 870 models for sale yet.

Should I choose a gas-operated or inertia-driven semi-auto?

Gas guns like the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus, A400 Solo, Browning Maxus II and Mossberg 940 shoot softer and run light dove loads better, but need cleaning more often. Inertia guns like the Benelli SBE3, Franchi Affinity 3 and Stoeger M3500 stay clean longer and carry lighter, but kick harder with magnum loads. Choose gas for comfort, inertia for low maintenance in mud and ice.

Can I use a 12-gauge shotgun for small upland birds?

Yes, the 12-gauge is highly versatile for upland hunting. By using lighter target loads and an Improved Cylinder or Skeet choke, you can hunt quail or woodcock without damaging the meat. Its wide shot string provides a more forgiving pattern for fast-flushing birds in thick cover.

Is a 3.5-inch chamber necessary for duck and goose hunting?

While 3-inch shells are sufficient for most waterfowl, a 3.5-inch chamber provides extra room for larger steel shot payloads. This is particularly useful for late-season geese at longer distances. Many modern hunters prefer the 3.5-inch option simply to ensure they can shoot any available ammunition.

How often should I clean my 12-gauge hunting shotgun?

Gas-operated shotguns should be cleaned every 250 to 500 rounds to prevent carbon buildup from slowing the action. Inertia and pump-action shotguns can go much longer, but you should always wipe down the exterior and bore after any hunt involving rain, snow, or salt spray.

What is the effective range of a 12-gauge for turkey hunting?

With modern Tungsten Super Shot (TSS) and an Extra-Full turkey choke, many 12-gauge shotguns are effective out to 50 or 60 yards. However, for traditional lead or bismuth loads, 40 yards remains the standard ethical limit to ensure enough pellet density for a clean kill.

Why would I choose an over-under shotgun for hunting?

Over-under shotguns like the Browning Citori offer two different chokes in one gun, allowing you to have a tight shot for far birds and an open shot for close ones. They are also shorter than semi-autos with the same barrel length, making them much easier to swing.

Does barrel length affect the power of a 12-gauge shotgun?

Barrel length has a negligible impact on the velocity or "power" of the shot. A 28-inch barrel is standard because it provides a better "swing" and a longer sight plane, which helps with lead and accuracy. Shorter 24-inch barrels are preferred for maneuverability in turkey blinds.

Is the Remington 870 still made?

Not right now, as far as buyers can tell. Remington’s current owner lists no 870 models or prices for sale, only a sign-up page for news. Used 870 Express and Wingmaster shotguns are still excellent hunting guns. For a new pump, the Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag, Mossberg 500 and Winchester SXP are all in production.

Is the Weatherby Element discontinued?

Yes. Weatherby lists the Element as no longer in production. It was replaced by the Element II, a 3-inch inertia semi-auto, which is under a safety recall for incorrectly heat-treated bolts (serial prefix TR7825-RL). Check that recall before buying an Element II, new or used.

For a deep-dive review of the gas-operated value champion in this segment, see our Beretta A300 Ultima review with full 500-round test data.

3,987+ Gun & Ammo Deals

Updated daily from 200+ top retailers. Filter by category, caliber, action type, and price.

Leave a Comment

Scroll back to top

The week's best gun and ammo deals, in one email

Picked from the 200+ retailers we track. Free, one email a week.