10 Best Shotguns for Home Defense (2025): Tried and Tested

Last Updated November 22nd 2025

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through our links, we can earn a small commission and keep hunting for the best shotguns for home defense at the best prices.

Best Shotguns for Home Defense Shotguns Comparison Table

Home defense is one of those topics that feels simple on the surface, but it gets real fast when you start looking at the guns, the layouts of real houses, the recoil loads, the stopping power, the pattern spread, and the way a shotgun actually handles in close quarters. I have spent enough time with pump shotguns, semi autos, mag fed monsters, and the occasional break action outlier to know what works when the lights are low and the distance is short.

A good shotgun gives you confidence. The controls feel familiar, the action cycles clean, the patterns are predictable, and the recoil is manageable even when you are tired or keyed up. There is a reason law enforcement and military units still trust a twelve gauge in tight spaces. The gauge works, the buckshot works, and the platform gives you the ability to solve the worst problems a homeowner can face.

I put together this list after months of handling everything from budget pump action shotguns to high end semi automatic shotguns. Some are soft shooting, some feel like they want to climb out of your hands, and some are so balanced you barely notice the cycling. This guide gives you the best options, the best setups, and the best choices for the real world.

1. Mossberg 590A1

• Price: $618.99+
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Pump action
• Capacity: 6+1
• Barrel: 18.5 inch
• Weight: 7 lb approx
• Best For: Proven tactical shotgun

Still the ultimate tactical pump action shotgun

The Mossberg 590A1 feels like a proper home defense weapon from the moment you pick it up. It is heavy, steady, and built to deal with close quarters without a complaint. The thicker barrel, the metal trigger guard, and the parkerized finish all add to that confidence. I have run this shotgun with buckshot, mini shells, high brass loads, and it cycles clean every time.

What makes the 590A1 special is the control. You get a smooth pump action, enough weight to soften recoil, and a layout that works with gloves or cold hands. The safety is on the tang, which helps left handed shooters or anyone who switches shoulders around doorways. The ghost ring sights are crisp. The shotgun feeds reliably, even when you are topping off the tubular magazine under pressure., the 590A1 gives you a simple equation. Point, cycle, shoot, and the gun stays on target.

The patterns are predictable. The recoil is manageable. It is a tactical shotgun that earns its reputation with real performance. Mossberg shotguns have been law enforcement and military staples for a long time and this one shows exactly why.

You can opt for a 9-shot 590A1, there’s a tactical version with AR-style furniture or you can go full retro with wood veneer furniture. And there are so many parts & accessories that it’s basically modular at this point. You can turn your 590A1 into a compact special with a raptor grip, a turkey gun and just about everything in between.

2. Beretta A300 Ultima Patrol

• Price: $1049.99+
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Semi auto
• Capacity: 7+1
• Barrel: 19.1 inch
• Weight: 7.1 lb
• Best For: Low recoil semi auto

Best semi-automatic shotgun for the money

The Beretta A300 Ultima Patrol feels refined. It is one of the softest shooting semi autos and the gas operated system takes most of the sting out of buckshot loads. The oversized controls, the enlarged loading port, and the extended magazine tube give you the feel of a premium tactical shotgun at a more grounded price.

I like the balance on this gun. It moves naturally, the recoil impulse is predictable, and the patterns stay tight with most common buckshot loads. The molded grip texture works in sweaty hands and the cheek weld is comfortable even during long sessions. The sighting system is simple but effective. A red dot mounts easily if you prefer it.

Inside a house this shotgun handles corners well. It is not as light as a Shockwave or a cruiser ready pump, but it is far easier to control. You get reduced recoil loads, clean cycling, and a proven platform from a company that has been building shotguns longer than most brands have existed. For home defense weapons, this one is hard to beat for soft shooting control.

3. Mossberg 590 Shockwave

• Price: $439.99+
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Pump action
• Capacity: 5+1
• Barrel: 14 inch
• Weight: 5.3 lb
• Best For: Compact cruiser ready

Best compact shotgun for indoor use

The Mossberg 590 Shockwave is one of those guns people see on the wall and assume it is just a novelty. It isn’t. In close quarters the Shockwave gives you unmatched mobility. It is compact, light weight, and very easy to move around furniture, corners, and doorways. You just need practice to control the recoil and pattern placement.

The raptor grip changes the way you hold the gun. You brace it low, pull tight, and let the gun rise naturally with the shot. Reduced recoil buckshot is your friend here. The gun cycles well, the forend moves smoothly, and the loading process is quick once you get the rhythm. This is not a full-stock shotgun, and it behaves differently, but the trade-off is speed and ease of movement.

The Shockwave works best in small rooms and tight spaces. You get five rounds on tap, a clean pump action, and a compact footprint that stays tight to the body. It is a cruiser ready defense weapon for people who want something small, fast, and reliable.

You can step it up a notch, too, with the Mossberg 590M Shockwave. The magazine-fed shotgun gives you up to 20 rounds, and totally transforms the gun, but the reliability can take a hit when you go that route.

4. Benelli M4 Tactical

• Price: $1,949.99
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Semi auto
• Capacity: 5+1 / 7+1 (tube dependent)
• Barrel: 18.5 inch
• Weight: 7.8 lb approx
• Best For: Premium shotgun

Greatest combat shotgun of all time

The Benelli M4 is the shotgun you buy when you want guaranteed performance, no excuses, no drama. This shotgun has been on duty with the Marine Corps for years. It cycles low brass, high brass, reduced recoil loads, and the full spread of buckshot without hesitation. I have run these in training and the gun just gets on with the job.

The gas system is the secret sauce. It keeps the recoil soft, the action clean, and the cycling consistent. The gun does weigh more than a pump action, but that weight stabilises the muzzle and keeps the gun flat under rapid fire. Everything about the M4 feels deliberate. The controls make sense, the loading port is predictable, and the overall build lives up to its reputation.

At home the M4 gives you confidence. It handles tight corners, stays manageable in close range fights, and carries enough capacity for most situations. It is not a budget shotgun. It is a lifetime gun. If you want the best semi automatic shotgun for home defense, you eventually circle back to the Benelli M4.

It’s the best semi-auto tactical shotgun in the world, and the absolute flag bearer if you can handle the sticker shock. Check out some of the best Benelli shotguns here if you love the brand, but want something a little lighter on your wallet.

5. Mossberg 940 Pro Tactical

• Price: $818.99+
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Semi auto
• Capacity: 7+1
• Barrel: 18.5 inch
• Weight: 7.25 lb approx
• Best For: Competition spec for sane money

Competition semi automatic shotguns for pump gun money

The Mossberg 940 Pro Tactical surprised me the first time I shot it. It is soft shooting, fast cycling, and much smoother than most shotguns in this price range. The gas system is designed to run dirty and keep going, and that matters when you want a reliable semi auto shotgun for tight defensive distances.

The shotgun handles reduced recoil loads better than most. It shoots flat. It stays on target. The controls are oversized and easy to hit. The loading port is opened up enough that you can top off without tearing your thumb. The stock geometry spreads the recoil and keeps the muzzle down, which matters the moment you start taking follow up shots.

You get everything you want. Capacity, reliability, a clean trigger, a proper sighting system, and the ability to push buckshot loads without shaking your teeth out. It works as a tactical shotgun, it works for competitive shooting, and it is one of the best semi autos you can buy for the money.

It’s the best semi-auto tactical shotgun in the world, and the absolute flag bearer if you can handle the sticker shock. Check out some of the best Benelli shotguns here if you love the brand, but want something a little lighter on your wallet.

6. IWI Tavor TS12

• Price: $1,288.99
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Semi auto, rotating mag-tube system
• Capacity: 15+1
• Barrel: 18.5 inch
• Weight: 8 lb approx
• Best For: High capacity mag fed performance

Massive capacity in a complex package

The IWI TS12 feels like stepping into a different category, a Wacky Races category to be honest. This is a semi automatic, mag-tube fed platform with enough capacity to handle almost anything that goes bump in the night. You get fifteen rounds on board without a drum magazine, and the rotating tube system keeps the footprint surprisingly compact.

The TS12 is heavier than a pump gun, but that weight makes it soft shooting. Reduced recoil loads feel almost polite. High brass buckshot stays manageable. The cycling is smooth, the gas system runs clean, and switching tubes becomes instinctive after a few practice sessions. I have run this shotgun fast, and it stays flat and predictable.

The TS12 gives you unmatched magazine capacity, but we do have question marks over the reliability of these complex bullpup shotguns and reloading on the fly isn’t that easy. It works as a defensive weapon in long hallways, staircases, and open living spaces. It is not the lightest shotgun here, but it delivers raw capability that few platforms can match.

7. Winchester SXP Defender

• Price: 312.99
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Pump or semi automatic depending on model
• Capacity: 5+1 to 8+1
• Barrel: 18.5 inch
• Weight: 6.25–7.5 lb range
• Best For: Bigger features on a budget

Best Budget Home Defense Shotgun

The Winchester Defender, or SXP Defender, is an underrated pump action with impressive speed. The rotating bolt gives the gun a fast, slick action that feels lighter than most pumps in this price range. I have put this gun through short room drills and the pump cycles as quickly as you can physically move the forend.

The SXP has a light weight build, a smooth slide release, and one of the easiest loading ports in the budget shotgun category. Recoil stays manageable. The gun uses simple bead sights or optional ghost rings depending on the model, and the shotgun patterns buckshot as consistently as anything else in its class.

A Winchester Defender gives you quick follow up shots, good ergonomics, and reliable cycling. It is easy to run, easy to maintain, and friendly for new shooters. It may not have the brand prestige of the 870 or 590, but it belongs in the conversation every time.

8. Black Aces Tactical Pro Series

• Price: 359.99
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Pump or semi auto depending on model
• Capacity: 5+1 to 8+1
• Barrel: 18.5 inch
• Weight: 6.5–7.5 lb range
• Best For: Bigger features on a budget

Best Budget Benelli Clone

The Black Aces Tactical Pro Series has built a following because it offers tactical features without tactical prices. Basically, it’s a cut-price Benelli M4 clone. I’ve shot several of these over the years. They feel basic in the hand, but they also do what they are supposed to do. You get ghost ring sights, pistol grips, mag tube extensions, and a proper defensive layout at a fraction of the cost of a Benelli or Beretta.

The pump versions cycle reliably once broken in. The semi autos prefer buckshot and run best with consistent ammunition. You get a shotgun that looks ready for competitive shooting and law enforcement use, but without the premium price tag. The fit and finish isn’t perfect, and the triggers feel simple, but the guns work.

All the controls are familiar, the recoil is predictable, and the overall package gives you serious stopping power for the money. It’s a solid defensive shotgun for buyers who want features first and cosmetics second.

9. Mossberg Maverick 88

• Price: $245.99
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Pump action
• Capacity: 5+1 / 7+1 (depending on model)
• Barrel: 18.5 inch
• Weight: 6.2 lb approx
• Best For: Saving money without sacrificing reliability

Cheapest reliable home defense shotgun

The Mossberg Maverick 88 is the shotgun I recommend when someone tells me they need a solid gun on the smallest possible budget. It’s the stripped-down sibling of the Mossberg 500. Same receiver design, same action, same reliability, just fewer frills and offshore assembly to keep the price low.

I’ve run multiple Maverick 88s through short courses, and they behave exactly the way you want a defensive pump action to behave. They feed buckshot, birdshot, and slugs without drama, the forend cycles smoothly, and the controls stay predictable even when you’re moving fast.

The cross-bolt safety is the biggest difference from the Mossberg 500, and I actually prefer it in a life or death situation. It’s less to think about, fewer parts to miss under stress. The 18.5-inch security model is the configuration to buy. Light, maneuverable, and everything you need for hallway distances.

The Maverick isn’t glamorous. It isn’t tactical. But it’s reliable, it’s cheap, and it works. If you’re looking for the best home defense shotgun under $250, this is the easiest recommendation on the list.

10. Remington 870 (Express / Police / Tactical Variants)

• Price: $549.99+
• Gauge: 12 gauge
• Action: Pump action
• Capacity: 4+1 to 6+1
• Barrel: 18–20 inch
• Weight: 7 lb approx
• Best For: Iconic pump action reliability

America’s best selling shotgun of all time

The Remington 870 is the best selling pump action shotgun ever. I have carried these on ranges, seen them in cruiser racks, and shot them in enough drills to know exactly how they behave. When you rack an 870 the action feels solid, the lockup is tight, and the gun cycles buckshot with confidence.

The 870 Police and the better Tactical models are the ones to buy. They use heavier carriers, stronger springs, and better extractors. The Express models still work, but the Police guns feel smoother and more predictable when you are tired or under stress. The forend tracks straight, the recoil pad helps, and the whole package stays controllable even with hot loads.

Inside the home the 870 handles like a proper defensive shotgun. It is long enough to keep the muzzle steady but short enough to move through tight hallways. You can run a ghost ring sight, a bead, or a small red dot. Topping off the tubular magazine is intuitive. If you want a pump action shotgun that simply works every time, the 870 still sits near the top of the list.

Read our full hands-on Remington 870 review here.

HOW TO CHOOSE A HOME DEFENSE SHOTGUN

Gauge: 12, 20, or .410

The 12 gauge is still the standard. It gives you the best mix of power, pattern consistency, and defensive load options. Reduced recoil buckshot makes it manageable, and mini shells add capacity in guns that cycle them well.

A 20 gauge is softer and easier to run fast. At hallway distances, it’s still extremely effective, especially with modern defensive loads. A .410 shotgun is workable only if recoil is a real problem, and only with proper buckshot. It’s the compromise option.

Action Type: Pump vs Semi Auto vs Mag Fed

A pump gun is simple, durable, and predictable. If you’ve trained the stroke, it runs anything and never complains. The downside is user error. Under stress, a sloppy pump stroke will slow you down or induce a malfunction.

Semi autos feel smoother, softer, and faster. Good gas guns run reduced-recoil loads and buckshot without drama, and most new shooters perform better with them. Mag-fed shotguns are hit-and-miss. The IWI TS12 is the one that actually works. For most people, a tube-fed pump or semi auto is still the safer, more intuitive choice.

Barrel Length and Indoor Handling

Your home is all about corners and tight spaces. An 18–18.5 inch barrel handles well indoors and stays balanced. 20 inches still works. Shockwave-style 14 inch guns are compact and fast, but harder to control without practice. A shotgun should move naturally with your support hand and stay stable when you lean or shift.

Capacity and Ammunition Management

Most defensive pumps run 5+1 or 6+1. Semi autos often match that or add one more. Higher capacity helps, because shotguns run dry fast and reloading under stress is slow. Tube-fed guns are easier to top off. A side saddle or card carrier is worth adding, because you’ll want backup rounds staged on the gun.

Sights, Optics, and Light Setup

Patterns stay tight indoors, so you need to aim. Ghost rings, fiber-optic beads, or a low-mounted red dot all work well. The critical accessory is a white light. You need positive identification in the dark before taking a shot. A good light with decent spill makes a bigger difference than any other upgrade.

Recoil Control and Fit

Recoil changes how a shotgun feels in tight rooms. A soft recoil pad, reduced recoil loads, and a stock that fits your shoulder all help. Pistol grip stocks give you leverage. Raptor grips are niche tools, not general solutions. A shotgun that fits you shoots flatter and keeps the muzzle in control through awkward angles.

HOME DEFENSE SHOTGUN BUYER’S GUIDE (2025)

A home defense shotgun sounds simple until you run it indoors. Tight corners, fast sight pictures, and stress highlight every flaw in your setup. Recoil, cycling speed, ergonomics, and pattern behavior matter more inside a house than they ever will on a square range.

I’ve run pumps and semis through shoothouse layouts, patterned loads at realistic distances, and tested how guns behave when you’re winded or rushed. Some stay predictable. Some fall apart. Here’s what actually matters.

Pump vs Semi Auto

Pumps are the workhorses. They’ll run anything, stay reliable with minimal maintenance, and deliver fight-stopping performance if you cycle them with authority. But they demand muscle memory. Under stress, short-stroking is the most common failure.

Semi autos remove that problem. Modern gas guns shoot softer, stay fast, and cycle reliably with defensive buckshot. For most shooters, especially under pressure, a semi auto is easier to run well. If you train regularly, a pump is rock solid. If you want the simplest path to confidence, a good semi auto is the easier choice.

12 vs 20 Gauge Shotguns

A 12 gauge remains the all-rounder. More load options, harder hits, and the most predictable patterns. Recoil is the only drawback.

A 20 gauge trades a little power for easier control and faster follow-up shots. With modern defensive loads, it’s completely viable at home-defense distances and often the better choice for recoil-sensitive shooters.

Barrel Length

18.5 inches feels right indoors. It moves quickly around corners, stays balanced, and keeps your sight picture stable. 20 inches is fine. Anything shorter needs paperwork and isn’t necessary.

Capacity

Shotguns run out of shells quickly. Reloads are slow. More rounds in the tube buy you time. 6+1 or 7+1 is where a defensive shotgun becomes comfortable. Add a side saddle so your support hand always has a shell ready.

Recoil Management

Indoor shooting exposes recoil issues fast. Awkward angles, leaning, cornering, and using a light all amplify muzzle rise. A gas-operated semi auto keeps the gun flatter and faster. Confidence matters here more than raw power.

Sights and Optics

At 7–15 yards, buckshot stays tight. You must aim. A ghost ring, fiber bead, or low red dot keeps things clean. Avoid bulky optics or anything mounted high. A quality weapon light is non-negotiable.

Patterning

Different loads behave differently. Some stay fist-tight. Others spread wider or throw fliers. Test your patterns at 5, 7, 10, and 15 yards with real defensive ammunition so you know exactly how your gun behaves indoors.

Best Ammo: Buckshot vs Slugs vs Birdshot

Buckshot

#1 Buckshot gives the best mix of pellet count and penetration. It’s extremely effective if your gun patterns it well.
00 Buckshot is the classic choice. Loads like Federal FliteControl stay tight and hit hard.
Low-recoil buckshot improves control and works in pumps and most modern semis.

Slugs

Slugs are niche. They’re great for barriers or exterior doors, but they overpenetrate indoors. Keep one or two on a side saddle, not in the tube.

Birdshot

Birdshot is not a defensive load. It may wound at very close range, but it lacks the penetration needed to stop a determined threat. Use real defensive ammunition.

Last Word

A good home defense shotgun isn’t complicated. It’s a tool. But it’s a tool that needs to work when nothing else does. Buy a gun you can run confidently. Pattern it. Add a proper light. Learn your holdovers. Practice your manipulations.

If you do that, any of the shotguns on this list will protect you and your home without hesitation.

FAQ – Home Defense Shotguns