15 Best Double Stack 1911 Pistols (2026): Tested & Ranked

Last updated August 23rd 2026 · By Nick Hall, double-stack 1911 shooter who has carried and competed with Staccatos and TTI Pit Vipers

Some of the links below are affiliate links, meaning at no additional cost to you, we may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.

Table of Contents

The Double Stack 1911 Market in 2026

The double stack 1911 market in 2026 looks nothing like it did two years ago. SIG Sauer dropped the P211 and shook the category. Staccato pivoted to Glock-compatible magazines with the HD line. Kimber brought a budget 2011 to market under $1,150, Tisas undercut everybody at $799, and Springfield announced a 3.5-inch compact Prodigy less than a week before this update. The days of spending $2,000 just to get into the platform are over.

I’ve been shooting and reviewing 2011s for years, and the pace of innovation right now is staggering. Magazine compatibility is the big story. Staccato’s HD line runs Glock 17 and 19 magazines. SIG’s P211 takes P320 mags. That means cheaper mags, more availability, and no more hoarding proprietary 2011 magazines at $50 a pop.

The 9mm vs 45 ACP debate still rumbles on, but the 2011 market has made its choice. Most of these guns chamber 9mm for a reason: when you can put 17 to 26 rounds through a match-grade barrel, the math changes completely. We’ve still got a 45 ACP option on this list for the traditionalists.

Fifteen guns made this list, from a $567 Rock Island to a $7,500 Taran Tactical. Two models that used to be on it have been discontinued by Armscor since the last update, and both are covered further down because dealers are still shifting them. For more 1911 options, check out our guide to the best custom 1911 handguns and the best cheap 1911 pistols under $500.

---

1. Staccato HD P4: Best Overall Double Stack 1911

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 4″
• Weight: 32 oz, per Staccato
• Capacity: 18+1 on the two Mec-Gar magazines in the box, 17+1 on a standard Glock 17 magazine
• Frame: Steel
• MSRP: $2,499

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
3/5	5/5	5/5	4.5/5	5/5

The Staccato HD P4 is the biggest story in the 2011 world for 2026, and it takes the top spot on this list for one simple reason: it runs Glock 17 magazines. That was the shock of SHOT Show 2026. The most trusted name in 2011 pistols just made the most popular pistol magazines in the world compatible with their platform.

Think about what that means. No more hunting for proprietary 2011 magazines at $50 each. Your buddy’s Glock mags work. The six Glock mags you already own work. Law enforcement agencies that already run Glocks can transition without replacing their entire magazine inventory. It’s a genuinely brilliant move.

The HD line uses a steel frame instead of the aluminum frame on the original P DPO. That adds some weight, but the recoil impulse is noticeably softer during rapid fire. The trigger is pure Staccato: crisp, short reset, and predictable. The one-piece sight block on the P4.5 variant is another nice touch that eliminates the common complaint about optic mounting plates.

Staccato built their reputation getting guns approved by the US Marshals and 280+ law enforcement agencies. The HD line is clearly aimed at expanding that even further. If you’re buying one 2011 in 2026, this is the one to get.

Best For: Shooters who want Staccato quality with the convenience of Glock magazine compatibility. Law enforcement professionals looking to upgrade from a Glock without losing their mag inventory.

---

2. SIG Sauer P211: Best New 2011 for 2026

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 4.2″ (GT4) / 4.4″ comp (GTO) / 5″ (GT5)
• Capacity: 17+1 / 21+1 (P320 magazines)
• Frame: Steel
• MSRP: ~$2,100 (GT4/GT5) / $2,399 (GTO)

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
3/5	4.5/5	4.5/5	4.5/5	4.5/5

SIG Sauer entering the 2011 market is like Toyota entering Formula 1. Everyone knew it was coming, and when it did, it changed the competitive landscape overnight. The P211 uses P320 magazines, which means millions of existing SIG owners already have compatible mags sitting in their safe.

The lineup covers all the bases. The GT4 is a 4.2-inch carry gun. The GT5 is a full-size 5-inch for competition and duty. The GTO is the flagship: 4.4 inches with an integrated compensator, a Trijicon SRO optic, and that glass-breaking single-action-only trigger that SIG is calling one of the best they’ve ever made.

SIG has the manufacturing scale to produce these in volume, which means availability should be better than the typical 2011 launch. The aftermarket will follow fast too. SIG accessories, holsters, and parts are everywhere. Combine that with the SIG Sauer reputation for military and law enforcement contracts, and you have a serious Staccato competitor from day one.

The only caveat is that it’s new. There’s no five-year track record yet. But SIG doesn’t release half-baked products, and early reports from reviewers and competition shooters have been very positive. This one is worth watching closely.

Best For: SIG P320 owners who want a 2011 without buying new magazines. Shooters who want the backing of one of the world’s largest firearms manufacturers behind their double stack 1911.

---

3. Dan Wesson DWX: Best CZ/1911 Hybrid

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 5″ (Full) / 4″ (Compact)
• Weight: 43 oz (Full)
• Capacity: 19+1 (Full) / 15+1 (Compact)
• Frame: Steel
• MSRP: $2,099 (Full) / $1,909 (Compact)

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
3.5/5	4.5/5	4.5/5	4.5/5	4.5/5

CZ owns Dan Wesson, and the DWX is what happens when two legendary platforms have a baby. The CZ 75 frame and grip angle paired with a 1911 fire control group, trigger, and safety creates something that feels familiar to both camps. At 19+1 capacity in the full-size model, it outguns most of the competition.

The big news for 2026: both the full-size and compact DWX are now available with optics-ready slides. That was the original model’s biggest weakness, and CZ-USA has fixed it. The DWX Compact with its 4-inch barrel and 15+1 capacity also makes a compelling carry option for shooters who want something different from the Staccato/SIG approach.

It isn’t a pure 1911 thanks to a locking breech barrel system rather than the traditional link system. The CZ 75’s takedown via the slide stop is also different. But what matters is that Dan Wesson build quality paired with that CZ 75 ergonomic magic. The squared-off trigger guard, weighted dust cover, and Picatinny rail give it a modern tactical look. The aggressive grip texture works without being abrasive during long sessions.

Dan Wesson makes great guns and this hybrid concept has earned its place near the top of any double stack 1911 list. See more Dan Wesson pistols here.

Best For: CZ fans who want a single-action trigger, 1911 enthusiasts who want more capacity, and shooters who appreciate a genuinely unique take on the 2011 concept.

---

4. Springfield Prodigy: Best High Capacity 2011

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 4.25″ / 5″
• Weight: ~32.5 oz
• Capacity: 17+1 (20+1 extended / 26+1 extended)
• Frame: Forged steel with polymer grip module
• MSRP: ~$1,499 (standard) / $1,599 (Comp)

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
4/5	3.5/5	4/5	4/5	3.5/5

The Springfield Armory Prodigy democratized the 2011 market. Before this gun, getting into a double stack 1911 meant spending $2,000 minimum. The Prodigy brought that down to under $1,500 and put 26+1 rounds of 9mm into the equation. That’s a staggering amount of firepower in a 1911 platform.

See our full Springfield Prodigy review for the full hands-on test.

The early production guns had teething issues. Accuracy complaints and occasional reliability hiccups made the first round of reviews mixed. Springfield has addressed most of those problems, and current production Prodigys are noticeably improved. The lineup has expanded too: you can now get a 3.5-inch compact, the standard 4.25 and 5-inch models, and a Comp version with an integrated compensator for $1,599.

A polymer grip module keeps weight manageable despite all that capacity. The Agency Optic System with swappable plates makes mounting your preferred red dot straightforward. Extended ambidextrous thumb safety, skeletonized hammer, and that Adaptive Grip Texture round out a strong package. It’s even better with a Hex Dragonfly red dot on top.

The Prodigy now faces stiffer competition from the Kimber DS Warrior at $1,099 and the eventual PSA Sabre-11, but that 26+1 extended capacity remains unmatched. If rounds on tap matter to you, nothing else comes close.

Best For: Shooters who want 2011 capacity without the $2,000+ entry price. Ideal first 2011 for someone stepping up from a striker-fired pistol.

---

5. Kimber 1911 DS Warrior: Best Value 2011

• Caliber: 9mm / .45 ACP / 10mm / .38 Super
• Barrel Length: 5″ / 6″ (Warrior LS 10mm)
• Weight: 28 oz (9mm Warrior LW) / 33 oz (steel .45, .38 Super, 10mm) / 36 oz (10mm Warrior LS)
• Capacity: 17+1 (9mm, 20-round magazines available) / 13+1 (.45 ACP, .38 Super, 10mm) / 15+1 (Warrior LS 10mm)
• Frame: Stainless slide with a carbon fiber grip module. Aluminum sub-frame on the 9mm Warrior LW, stainless sub-frame on the rest
• MSRP: $1,135 (9mm Warrior LW) to $1,395 (10mm Warrior LS). Kimber quotes a street price of $999 to $1,099

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
4.5/5	3.5/5	4/5	4/5	3/5

Kimber entering the budget 2011 space was inevitable, and the 1911 DS Warrior is their answer. At $1,099, it undercuts the Springfield Prodigy by $400 and puts the Kimber name on a double stack 1911 that regular shooters can actually afford. That price point is going to move a lot of units.

The caliber options are the standout feature here. Where most 2011s are 9mm only, Kimber is offering the DS Warrior in 9mm, .45 ACP, 10mm, and .38 Super. A double stack 10mm 2011 at this price is genuinely unprecedented. That alone will attract a specific crowd of handgun hunters and power-factor competition shooters.

The gun runs a 5-inch barrel, polymer grip module on a steel frame, and comes optics ready. At 33 oz unloaded, it’s in the same weight class as the Springfield Prodigy. Kimber has a mixed reputation for QC on their traditional 1911s, so the DS Warrior will need to prove itself over time. But the spec sheet and the price tag are both very compelling.

Best For: Budget-conscious buyers who want a name-brand 2011, and shooters who want a double stack 1911 in 10mm or .38 Super without spending custom-shop money.

---

6. Wilson Combat EDC X9 2.0: Best Premium Carry Double Stack

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 4″ on the X9 2.0, 3.25″ on the X9S 2.0
• Weight: 29.5 oz unloaded
• Capacity: 15+1, with 18-round magazines available
• Frame: 7075-T6 aluminum with an integral magwell
• MSRP: From $3,150. Our retailer feed currently runs $3,231 to $3,850

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
1.5/5	5/5	5/5	5/5	5/5

The EDC X9 is the gun that proved a double stack 1911 could be carried all day rather than shot all weekend. Bill Wilson built it around a shortened, slimmed grip that hides 15 rounds without the fence-post circumference of a competition 2011, and the 2.0 refresh added a squared trigger guard, better slide serrations and an optics cut that does not need the slide sent away.

What you are paying for is fit. Slide-to-frame lockup has no perceptible play, the trigger breaks at about 3.5 lb with almost no take-up, and the magwell is machined into the frame rather than bolted on. Wilson also sells the X9S 2.0 with a 3.25-inch barrel if you want the same gun in a smaller package.

Worth knowing before you commit. Wilson released the eXperior Elite Commander Double Stack in April 2026 at $3,999, an 18-round Commander-size gun on a 7075 aluminum frame at 32.9 oz. None of our retailers stock it, so that one you order direct from Wilson.

Best For: Someone who wants a genuinely carryable 1911 with double stack capacity and does not flinch at custom-shop money.

---

7. Tisas 1911 Duty B9R: Best Budget Double Stack 1911

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 5″
• Weight: about 38 oz
• Capacity: 17+1, with two 17-round magazines in the box
• Frame: Forged steel with a double stack grip
• MSRP: $799.99. Our retailer feed currently runs $698 to $733

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
5/5	3/5	4/5	3.5/5	2.5/5

Tisas has spent five years quietly becoming the reason nobody has to spend $1,000 on a first 1911, and the Duty B9R applies the same logic to the double stack. Seventeen rounds, a forged steel frame, an optics cut and a rail, for less than two magazines cost on a Staccato.

It’s heavier than the alloy-framed guns above it at roughly 38 oz, and the weight is doing real work. Recoil stays flat, the gun tracks well, and the extra mass forgives a lot of technique. The trigger is the giveaway that you have not spent $2,000. Clean enough. Just not the glass-rod break you get from the Dan Wesson upward.

This slot used to belong to the Rock Island TAC Ultra FS HC in 9mm. Armscor has discontinued that model, so the Tisas takes over as the cheapest double stack 1911 you can still order new.

Best For: A first double stack 1911, or anyone who wants the platform without the platform tax.

---

8. Nighthawk Custom TRS Commander: Ultimate Luxury 2011

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 4.25″
• Capacity: 17+1
• Frame: Steel
• MSRP: ~$3,999

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
1/5	5/5	5/5	5/5	5/5

The Nighthawk Custom TRS Commander is the Patek Philippe of handguns. Most of us are happy with a Casio. But for the 1% who want the absolute best, and for people who just really love guns, nothing touches a Nighthawk.

Every TRS is built by a single gunsmith from start to finish. No assembly lines, no shortcuts, no compromises. The result is a gun that feels like it was made specifically for your hand. The slide-to-frame fit produces that satisfying bank-vault lockup that 1911 enthusiasts chase their whole lives.

You can get the TRS in 9mm, 45 ACP, 10mm, or 30 Super Carry. Compact, commander, or full size. The double stack frame gives you 17+1 in 9mm without feeling oversized. Nighthawk also released several new models for 2026, so the lineup keeps growing for those with the budget.

Best For: Collectors and shooters who want the absolute pinnacle of 1911 craftsmanship with modern double stack capacity. The “buy once, cry once” choice.

---

9. TTI Pit Viper / Sand Viper: Coolest Custom 2011

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 5″ + compensator
• Weight: 40 oz
• Capacity: 20+1
• Frame: Machined billet steel
• MSRP: ~$7,500+

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
0.5/5	5/5	4.5/5	5/5	5/5

The TTI Pit Viper took center stage in John Wick 4, and you can buy one yourself if you have $7,500 and the patience for a 6 to 9 month wait. Taran Butler built this gun from the ground up after modifying STI handguns for John Wick 3 and Glocks for JW2. Read our full TTI Pit Viper review for the deep dive.

Everything is machined from billet. The single-port compensator tames recoil but requires 124gr or heavier ammunition to cycle reliably. The full-length DLC coated barrel, enlarged ejection port, Aftec extractor, and that 1.75 to 2.25 lb trigger create the ultimate competition pistol. The Cerakote finish is top quality throughout.

The Sand Viper is optics ready while the Pit Viper is not. Night sights, seamlessly blended beavertail grip safety, accessory rail, and wraparound stippling complete the package. Is it worth $7,500? For most people, no. For competition shooters and John Wick fans with the budget, nothing else scratches this itch.

Best For: Competition shooters with serious budgets, John Wick fans who want the real thing, and collectors who appreciate hand-built firearms at the highest level.

---

10. Staccato P: The Proven Classic

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 4.4″
• Weight: 33 oz
• Capacity: 17+1 (20+1 extended)
• Frame: 7075 Aluminum with polymer grip
• MSRP: ~$2,500 – $2,800

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
2.5/5	4.5/5	5/5	4.5/5	5/5

The Staccato P DPO was the king of this list for years, and it’s still an incredible gun. Approved by the US Marshals Special Operations Group and over 280 law enforcement agencies, it has the most proven track record of any 2011 on the market. That’s not marketing fluff. Agencies don’t stake officers’ lives on a gun that hasn’t earned total trust.

So why is it at number 10? Two reasons. First, Staccato’s own HD line has overtaken it with steel-frame construction and Glock magazine compatibility. Second, the proprietary 2011 magazines are expensive and increasingly feel like a relic in a market moving toward common mag platforms. The gun itself hasn’t gotten worse. The competition just got a lot better.

The P still delivers match-grade accuracy, the Dawson Precision Optic cut takes your favorite red dot, and the wraparound stippling and flared magwell are excellent. The company started as STI and starred in John Wick 3 before the rebrand. If you find a good deal on a P DPO, it remains one of the finest 2011s ever made.

Best For: Shooters who want a battle-tested 2011 with the longest track record in law enforcement. Still an excellent choice if you already have Staccato 2011 magazines.

---

11. Bul Armory SAS II: Competition-Grade Israeli 2011

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 4.25″ / 5″
• Capacity: 17+1 / 21+1
• Frame: Aluminum
• MSRP: $2,250 for the SAS II TAC 4.25″, $2,650 for the Air, up to $4,890 for the Bullesteros

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
3.5/5	4/5	4.5/5	4.5/5	3.5/5

The Bul Armory SAS II was the open secret of the 2011 world for years. Built in Israel and used extensively in IPSC competition, these guns had a reputation among serious shooters but were nearly impossible to find in the US. Availability has improved through Bul Armory USA and dealers like Rainier Arms, though some configurations still come and go.

The SAS II range spans from the EDC at $1,850 to full competition models above $3,000. The TAC Pro models feature ported barrels, lightening cuts on the slide, and genuine race gun touches. A new TAC Pro Comp variant with integrated compensator dropped in late 2025. The trigger on these guns is outstanding, comparable to guns costing significantly more.

The challenge for Bul Armory in 2026 is relevance. With SIG, Staccato HD, Kimber, and Springfield all fighting for the same buyers, the SAS II needs US distribution and brand awareness to keep pace. For shooters who know what they’re looking at, this remains one of the best-kept secrets in the 2011 world.

Best For: IPSC and USPSA competitors who want proven match-grade performance. Shooters who value substance over brand hype.

---

12. Rock Island Armory Rock Ultra HC: Best 10mm Double Stack 1911

• Caliber: 10mm Auto
• Barrel Length: 5″
• Weight: 2.5 lb, so 40 oz unloaded
• Capacity: 16+1
• Frame: Forged steel
• Overall Length: 8.74″
• MSRP: $695. Our retailer feed currently shows it at $567

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
5/5	2.5/5	4/5	3/5	2/5

If you want a double stack 1911 in 10mm and you don’t want to spend Kimber money, this is more or less the only answer. Sixteen rounds of 10mm in a forged steel 1911 frame, at a price that reads like a typo next to everything else on this list.

And the weight is the point. At 40 oz the Rock Ultra turns full-power 10mm into something closer to a brisk .45, which matters if you shoot it for more than a magazine at a time. Armscor has never pretended these are showpieces. The finish is plain, the sights are basic, and the machining marks sit where you would expect them at the price. What they do is run.

Note that Armscor has discontinued the BBR 3.10 that used to hold this slot, along with the 9mm TAC Ultra FS HC. The Rock Ultra HC is the survivor of that lineup and the one still worth buying new.

Best For: A 10mm shooter who wants capacity and does not care what the gun looks like.

---

13. Kimber KDS9c: Best Compact Double Stack for Carry

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 4.09″
• Weight: 25.3 oz unloaded
• Capacity: 15+1, with 18-round magazines available
• Frame: Aluminum with a steel slide
• MSRP: $1,495, rising to $1,903 for the Rail version. Our retailer feed currently runs $914 to $1,474

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
4/5	4/5	4/5	4.5/5	3.5/5

The KDS9c is the gun that got Kimber taken seriously in the 2011 conversation, and it did it by going small rather than going cheap. At 25.3 oz with an aluminum frame it weighs less than a Glock 19 while carrying 15 rounds behind a single-action 1911 trigger.

That combination is rarer than it sounds. Most double stack 1911s solve the recoil problem with mass, which is fine on a range and miserable on a belt. The KDS9c accepts the trade instead, and the 4.09-inch barrel and lighter slide make it noticeably livelier in the hand than a Staccato C2.

Don’t confuse it with the 1911 DS Warrior at number five. The Warrior is the full-size value gun on a traditional 1911 slide. The KDS9c is a purpose-built compact with its own frame, and the two share very little beyond the badge.

Best For: Anyone who wants a 1911 trigger on a carry gun and finds the Wilson EDC X9 too expensive.

---

14. Girsan Witness2311: Cheapest Way Into the Platform

• Caliber: 9mm, .45 ACP and 10mm
• Barrel Length: 3.4″ on the compact models, up to 5″ on the Match
• Capacity: 17+1 in 9mm, 11+1 in .45 ACP, 15+1 in 10mm
• Frame: Steel, with a polymer or aluminum grip module by model
• MSRP: $769 for the Brat, $999 for the standard, $1,099 for the Match, $1,199 for the Match X. Our retailer feed currently runs $700 to $730

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
5/5	3/5	3.5/5	3.5/5	2/5

EAA has been importing Girsan pistols for years, and the Witness2311 is the line that finally put a double stack 1911 inside reach of someone who is not saving up for it. Seventeen rounds of 9mm, a steel frame and an optics cut, for the price of a decent red dot on its own.

The range is wider than most people realise. The Brat is the budget entry, the standard 2311 is the full-size gun, and the Match and Match X move up into competition trim. The CMXX adds a compensator in 10mm, which is an unusual thing to find under $1,200.

Set expectations properly and it is a lot of gun. Set them at Staccato level and you will be disappointed. The trigger, the finish and the fit are all where a $700 pistol lands, and none of that stops it shooting well enough to learn the platform on.

Best For: A first double stack 1911 on a tight budget, or a spare gun that will get abused.

---

15. Springfield 1911 DS Prodigy 3.5″ AOS: The Newest Double Stack 1911 on Sale

• Caliber: 9mm
• Barrel Length: 3.5″
• Capacity: 15+1 or 18+1 depending on which magazines your retailer ships. Both configurations are in the feed, plus a 10-round version for restricted states
• Frame: Forged steel with a polymer grip module
• Optic: Agency Optic System plates
• MSRP: $1,582. Our retailer feed currently runs $1,336 to $1,469

Price	Fit & Finish	Reliability	Trigger	Prestige
4/5	4/5	4/5	4.5/5	3.5/5

Springfield announced this one five days before this update went live, and it’s the most interesting thing to happen at the affordable end of the category this year. The Prodigy already democratised the 2011. The 3.5-inch AOS shrinks it to something you can actually conceal.

The important detail is magazine sharing. It runs the same 1911 DS magazines as the full-size Prodigy, so a flush 15 or 18 rounds for carry and a 20 or 26-round stick for the range, out of one pile of magazines. That is the practical advantage the compact 2011s from other makers do not have.

One caution worth repeating. Retailers are listing it with two 15-round magazines, with two 18-round magazines, and in a 10-round restricted-state configuration, all at similar prices. Read the SKU before you click buy.

Best For: Someone who wants the newest compact double stack and already owns Prodigy magazines.

---

2011 vs Double Stack 1911: What Actually Separates Them

The two terms get used interchangeably and they are not the same thing. A 2011 uses a two-piece frame. The steel or aluminum chassis holds the fire control, and a separate grip module bolts to it, which is what lets the grip be wide enough for a staggered magazine without the frame rails moving. STI patented that layout, the patent expired, and the whole current market grew out of it.

A double stack 1911 keeps the original one-piece frame and simply widens it. The Rock Island Rock Ultra, the Tisas Duty B9R and the Kimber 1911 DS Warrior all work that way. You get a more familiar 1911 takedown and a lower price. You also get a chunkier grip, because the frame has to carry both the rails and the magazine width.

Neither is better in the abstract. Two-piece guns let a maker tune the grip circumference and swap a damaged module, and they dominate competition for that reason. One-piece guns are simpler, cheaper to build and easier to get parts for. In practice the price tells you which you are looking at more reliably than the name does.

Magazines Are the Hidden Running Cost

Nobody buying their first double stack 1911 budgets for the magazines, and they should. A competition shooter wants six to eight of them, and on a 2011-pattern gun that is a four-figure line item on its own. This is the single biggest reason the Glock-compatible and P320-compatible guns landed the way they did.

The table below is the part no other buying guide publishes. It’s what each gun on this list actually eats, and whether spares are a commodity you can buy anywhere or a proprietary part you order and wait for.

Read it alongside the prices. A Staccato HD P4 and a Staccato P are within a couple of hundred dollars of each other, and the HD feeds from magazines that cost roughly a third as much. Over eight magazines that gap is larger than the price difference between the guns.

Discontinued, But Still on Dealer Shelves

Two Rock Island double stacks that used to sit on this list have been discontinued by Armscor. Both are still turning up new in dealer stock, so they are worth knowing about rather than pretending they never existed.

Rock Island TAC Ultra FS HC 9mm. Seventeen rounds, 5-inch barrel, forged steel, 2.7 lb. MSRP was $899. Armscor lists it as discontinued. The .45 ACP 14-round version of the same gun is still in the catalogue.

Rock Island BBR 3.10. A 3.1-inch double stack in .45 ACP holding 10+1 at 2 lb, MSRP $699. Also discontinued, and still showing up in the feed around $539 to $600. If you want a compact .45 double stack it is the cheapest one that exists, with the obvious caveat that support gets harder from here.

Related Handgun Guides

• Handgun Buyer’s Guide
• Best Cheap 1911 Pistols
• Best 1911s Under $2000
• Best Full Size 9mm Pistols
• Best Online Gun Stores

FAQ: Double Stack 1911 Pistols

Head-to-head comparisons: See how the top double-stack 2011s match up in our Staccato vs Springfield Prodigy, Wilson EDC X9 vs Staccato C2, Wilson Combat vs Staccato, and Nighthawk vs Staccato guides.